•  
  •  
 

DOI

10.21143/jhp.vol56.no.3.2920

Abstract

One aspect of evaluating the Constitutional Court, which has been in existence since 2003, is the issue of ethical compliance. Although a code of ethics for constitutional judges currently exists, it applies only to sitting constitutional judges. In reality, however, many former constitutional judges frequently act as parties in cases heard by the Constitutional Court. The author found that there are still former Constitutional Court judges who have served as parties—either as principals or as legal representatives. Although there is no explicit prohibition, the involvement of former constitutional judges in case proceedings raises the potential for conflicts of interest and has led to decline in public trust in the judicial system. To analyze the urgency of a code of ethics for former judges, the author employs a normative legal approach based on the doctrines of the  appearance of impropriety an the dignity of office. The author draws a comparison with Germany, which has established ethical guidelines  for former constitutional judges. The goal is to avoid public suspicion that could undermine the integrity of the judges and the prestige of the Constitutional Court. This practice is an interesting issue because it imposes clear restrictions on former judges, which has been shown to improve the quality of adjudication at the German Federal Constitutional Court, as evidenced by the country’s ranking as fifth in the Rule of Law Index. The author recommends recommends restrictions on the involvement of former constitutional judges in cases before the Constitutional Court through the addition of new provisions to the judges’ code of ethics.

Bahasa Abstract

Evaluasi keberadaan Mahkamah Konstitusi yang sudah berdiri sejak 2003 salah satunya adalah dalam isu penegakan etik. Meskipun saat ini telah ada kode etik hakim konstitusi, namun kode etik tersebut hanya berlaku untuk hakim konstitusi. Padahal, dalam kenyataannya, mantan hakim konstitusi banyak yang kerap menjadi para pihak dalam perkara yang diselesaikan di MK. Penulis menemukan masih adanya mantan hakim MK yang pernah menjadi para pihak baik menjadi prinsipal maupun sebagai kuasa hukum. Meskipun tidak ada larangannya, namun  keterlibatan mantan hakim konstitusi dalam proses pemeriksaan perkara menimbulkan potensi konflik kepentingan dan berdampak pada menurunnya kepercayaan publik terhadap institusi peradilan. Untuk menganalisis urgensi kode etik bagi mantan hakim, penulis menggunakan metode yuridis normatif dengan menggunakan doktrin appearance of impropriety dan dignity of office. Penulis melakukan perbandingan dengan Negara Jerman yang mempunyai praktek pengaturan norma etik untuk mantan hakim konstitusi. Tujuannya adalah untuk menghindari dugaan publik yang dapat menurunkan integritasi hakim serta  marwah Mahkamah Konstitusi. Praktek ini menjadi isu menarik karena memberikan batasan yang tegas terhadap mantan hakim yang ternyata berdampak pada peningkatan kualitas peradilan di Federal Constitutional Court Jerman yang dibuktikan dengan keberhasilan negara ini menjadi negara peringkat kelima dalam indeks rule of law. Penulis merekomendasikan adanya batasan keterlibatan mantan hakim konstitusi dalam proses berperkara di Mahkamah Konstitusi dengan penambahan norma baru dalam kode etik hakimnya.

References

American Bar Association, Model Code of Judicial Conduct, https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_code_of_judicial_conduct/   

Angraini, Fauziah Suci. Pro Kontra Penegakan Etik Secara Internal dan Eksternal, Jurnal Konstitusi & Demokrasi: Vol. 1: No. 1, Article 3, 2021, DOI: 10.7454/JKD.v1i1.1103     

Asshiddiqie, Jimly. Hukum Acara Pengujian Undang-Undang. Jakarta: Sekretariat Jenderal dan Kepaniteraan MK RI,2005.

Bayefksy, Rachel. Dignity and Judicial Authority, Oxford University Press, 2024

Beijing Statement Of Principles Of The Independence Of The Judiciary In The Lawasia Region https://www.icj.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Beijing-Statement.pdf  

Buquicchio, Role of The Judiciary in A Democratic Society: Relation Between the Executive and the Judiciary, https://rm.coe.int/proceedings-of-the-conference-on-strengthening-judicial-independence-s/16808b64d4 

Biro Humas dan Protokol MKRI, Peningkatan Kualitas Layanan Publik: Penilaian Kepuasan Terhadap Pelayanan, 2025.

Blackshield, A. R. A Pelican In The Wilderness: Some Reflections On Re-Reading Lord Lloyd’s The Idea Of Law. Journal of Legal Education, 19(2), 127–167. (1966). http://www.jstor.org/stable/42896669

Code of Conduct fot the Justices of the Federal Constitutional Court, diakses dari https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/EN/TheFederalConstitutionalCourt/Justices/CodeOfConduct/codeofconduct_node.html

Canadian Judicial Council Releases Revised Ethical Princip,es for Judges, diakses dari https://www.canadianlawyermag.com/resources/professional-regulation/canadian-judicial-council-releases-revised-ethical-principles-for-judges/357274

Capurso, Timohty J. How Judges Judge: Theories on Judicial Decision Making, University of Baltimore Law Forum: Vol. 29 :No. 1 , Article 2, 1998, https://scholarworks.law.ubalt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1909&context=lf 

Consultative Council of European, Questionaire for the Preparation of the CCJE Opinion No. 14 (2014), diakses dari https://rm.coe.int/CoERMPublicCommonSearchServices/DisplayDCTMContent?documentId=090000168046abb0  pada 14 Desember 2024

Code of Conduct for the Justice of the Federal Constitutional Court , diakses dari  https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/EN/TheFederalConstitutionalCourt/Justices/CodeOfConduct/codeofconduct_node.html

Deutscher Richterbund, Judicial Ethic in Germany, diakses dari https://www.drb.de/fileadmin/DRB/pdf/Ethik/1901_DRBBroschuere_Richterethik_EN_Judicial_Ethics.pdf  

Dicey, AV. An Introduction to the Study of The Law of The Constitution. London:The Macmillan Press, 1979.

Delhi High Court, High Court of Bombay vs Uday Singh on April, 1997, diakses dari https://indiankanoon.org/doc/613638/

Deutsche Welle, Spotlight on German Judges, diakses dari https://www.dw.com/en/german-judges-drafting-their-own-ethics-codex/a-37675097

Faiz, Pan Mohammad. Kode Etik Mantan Hakim Konstitusi, Perlukah? Kolom “Ruang Konstitusi” di MAJALAH KONSTITUSI No. 136, Juni 2018, diakses dari https://panmohamadfaiz.com/2018/07/16/kode-etik-mantan-hakim-konstitusi-perlukah/ 

Federal Civil Servant Act (Bundesbeamtengesetz-BBG), Section 77 Paragraph 1, juncto Section 46 DRiG untuk hakim federal dan the Status on Civil Servant Act

Germany Ranks 5th out of 142 in Rule of Law index, diakses dari https://worldjusticeproject.org/sites/default/files/documents/Germany_1.pdf. 

Guanire, Carlo. Professional Qualification of The Judiciary in Italy, France and Germany, diakses dari https://birosag.hu/sites/default/files/7._sz._melleklet_-_gcr_chapter_3_final.pdf

Germany Constitution 1949, diakses dari https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/German_Federal_Republic_2014 

German Judiciary Act

Graver, Hans Petter. “Why Adolf Hitler Spared the Judges: Judicial Opposition Against the Nazi State.” German Law Journal 19, no. 4 (2018): 845–78. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2071832200022896.

Hans Petter, Graver “Why Adolf Hitler Spared the Judges: Judicial Opposition Against the Nazi State.” German Law Journal 19, no. 4 (2018): 845–78. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2071832200022896.

Haryatmoko, Etika Publik: Untuk Integritas Pejabat Publik dan Politisi. Yogyakarta: Kanisius, 2015.

Hermann, Donald HJ. Max Weber and the Concept of Legitimacy in Contemporary Jurisprudence, DePaul Law Review, Vol. 33, Issue 1, 1983, https://via.library.depaul.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2229&context=law-review

Code of Judicial Ethic, https://www.unodc.org/res/ji/import/codes_of_conduct/iberoamerican_code_of_conduct/iberoamerican_code_of_ethics_english.pdf

Index of Public Integrity, diakses dari https://corruptionrisk.org/integrity/Shetreet, Shimon. Judicial Independence: the Contemporary Debate. Netherlands:Martinus Nijhoff Publisher, 1985.

Ketetapan MPR Nomor VI/MPR/2001 tentang Etika Kehidupan Berbangsa dan Bernegara

Kode Etik dan Perilaku Hakim Konstitusi Republik Indonesia, diakses dari https://www.mkri.id/public/content/dewanetik/kode%20etik.pdf

Labor Law PH, Post-Employment Restrictions, diakses dari https://laborlaw.ph/post-employment-restrictions/

Mahkamah Konstitusi Republik Indonesia, Ahli PDIP Sebut Permohonan Tak Sesuai Peraturan MK, diakses dari https://www.mkri.id/berita/ahli-pdip-sebut-permohonan-tak-sesuai-peraturan-mk-21010

Mahkamah Konstitusi Republik Indonesia, Risalah Sidang Perkara Nomor 25/PUU-XIV/2016, diakses dari https://www.mkri.id/public/content/persidangan/risalah/risalah_sidang_8683_PERKARA%20NOMOR%2025.PUUXIV.2016%20tgl%207%20Juni%202016.pdf  

Mantan Hakim MK Aswanto Jadi Saksi Ahli di Sidang Sengketa Pileg 2024, diakses dari https://news.detik.com/pemilu/d-7359753/mantan-hakim-mk-aswanto-jadi-saksi-ahli-di-sidang-sengketa-pileg-2024.

Mahkamah Konstitusi RI, PMK Nomor 2 Tahun 2003, Pasal 49 ayat (2).

McKoski, Raymond J. Judicial Discipline and the Appearance of Impropriety: What the Public Sees Is What the Judge Gets, Minesota Law Review, https://biblioteca.cejamericas.org/bitstream/handle/2015/2254/JudicialDiscipline-and-the-Appearance-of-Impropriety.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

Pedro C. Magalhães & Nuno Garoupa (2023) Populist governments, judicial independence, and public trust in the courts, Journal of European Public Policy, DOI: 10.1080/13501763.2023.2235386

Post-Retirement Appointments: a Danger to Judicial Independence, diakses dari https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/post-retirement-appointments-a-danger-to-judicial-independence/article66512025.ece

Republik Indonesia, UU tentang Kekuasaan Kehakiman, UU Nomor 48 Tahun 2009 

Resolution of Budapest on Self-Governance for the Judiciary, diakses dari https://judicialethicsplatform.nij.bg/docs/budapest-resolution-on-selfgovernance-for-the-judiciary-balancing-independence-and-accountability-encj-2008/   

Rahayu, Prasetianingsih. “Akuntabilitas Kekuasaan Kehakiman”. Jurnal Konstitusi 8 (5):829-48. 2016. https://doi.org/10.31078/jk858.

Rotunda, Ronald. D. Judicial Ethics, The Appearance of Impropriety and the Proposed New ABA Judicial Code, Hofstra Law Review, Vol. 34, 2006

Sundariwati, Ni Luh Dewi 2024. “Judicial Activism: Between Protecting Constitutional Supremacy or Transitioning to Juristocracy: Judicial Activism: Diantara Melindungi Supremasi Konstitusional Atau Transisi Menuju Juristocracy”. Jurnal Konstitusi 21 (3):432-47. https://doi.org/10.31078/jk2135.

Shetreet, Shimon. Judicial Independence: the Contemporary Debate, Netherlands:Martinus Nijhoff Publisher, 1985

The Finnish Section of the International Commission of Jurists, Report of the Symposium on “The Independence of Judges and Lawyer, Helsinski, 1981”, diakses dari https://www.icj.org/wp-content/uploads/1981/01/independence-of-judges-and-lawyers-conference-report-1981-eng.pdf

United Kingdom Supreme Court, Guide to Judicial Conduct, diakses dari https://www.supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc_guide_to_judicial_conduct_a456af62f8.pdf  

Yuliana, Adelia, dkk, Analisis Tingkat Kepercayaan Publik Terhadap Mahkamah Konstitusi Pasca Putusan Nomor 90/PUU-XXI/2023, Jurnal Hukum Statuta, Vol. 3. No. 2, Tahun 2024

Yusuf Warsyim dan Harmoko, Politik Hukum Pengawasan dan Penegakan Kode Etik dan Perilaku Hakim Konstitusi, Jurnal Konstitusi Vol. 22 Issue 2, 2025, https://doi.org/10.31078/jk2229

Share

COinS