•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Abstract

The Natuna waters have recently been a flashpoint between China and Indonesia as a result of China's vague claim of a nine dash line (9DL). It has caused a number of incidents and standoffs between legal enforcement agencies of both countries and sparked a diplomatic row.

This article explores how the ambiguous claim of a historic right/9DL was gradually introduced by China and then coercively applied in the Natuna waters. It also attempts to identify what China actually claims in the waters. It will then examine how Indonesia under the Jokowi administration responds to the claims, and elaborate what measures Indonesia has taken and will continue to take in order to protect its maritime interests against China’s 9DL claim. It concludes that Indonesia regards China’s illegal claim as a matter of principle and thus takes an uncompromising stand.

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

i) Legal Documents

Agreement between the Government of Malaysia and the Government of Indonesia on the Delimitation of the Continental Shelves between the Two Countries. 27 October 1969. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.un.org/depts/los/LEGISLATIONANDTREATIES/PDFFILES/TREATIES/MYSIDN1969CS.PDF

Joint Statement of the ASEAN-China Special Summit to Commemorate the 30th Anniversary of ASEAN-China Dialogue Relations: Comprehensive Strategic Partnership for Peace, Security, Prosperity and Sustainable Development, 22 November 2021.

Philippines Supreme Court. 16 July 2011. Prof. Merlin M. Magallona, et.al. v. Hon. Eduardo Ermita, in his capacity as Executive Secretary, et al. G.R. No. 187167.

PCA, 2016. Arbitral Tribunal on 12 July 2016 Constituted under Annex VII to the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea between the Philippines and China, PCA Award Case No 2013-19.

ii) Books and books chapters

Agusman, Damos. “The Battle of Notes Verbales and the Future of South China Sea in The Notes Verbales Debate and the Future of the COC Negotiations and Cooperation in the South China Sea.” Diplomatic Academy of Vietnam 2. (2021).

Bentley, Scott. The Maritime Fulcrum of the Indo-Pacific: Indonesia and Malaysia Respond to China’s Creeping Expansion in the South China Sea. China Maritime Studies Institute. U.S. Naval War College, 2023.

Butcher, John G and Elson, R. E. Sovereignty and the Sea: How Indonesia Became an Archipelagic State. National University of Singapore Press, 2017.

Djalal, Hasjim. Perjuangan Indonesia di bidang Hukum Laut. Bina Cipta, 1979.

Hayton, Bill. The South China Sea: The Struggle for Power in Asia. Yale University Press, 2014.

Hayton, Bill. The Invention of China. Yale University Press, 2020.

Lo, Chi-kin. China’s Policy toward Territorial Disputes, the Case of South China Sea Islands. Routledge, (1989).

Note: nama penulis adalah Chin-kin Lo -> https://www.routledge.com/Chinas-Policy-Towards-Territorial-Disputes-The-Case-of-the-South-China/Lo/p/book/9780415009270

Talmon, Stefan & Jia, Bing Bing eds. The South China Sea Arbitration: A Chinese Perspective. Hart Publishing. 2014.

Valencia, Mark J., Dyke, Jon M. van., & Ludwig, Noel A. Sharing the Resources of the South China Sea. University of Hawaii Press, 1999.

iii) Journals and periodicals

Agusman, Damos. “The South China Sea UNCLOS Tribunal Award 2016: What It has Changed and What It Does Mean to Indonesia.” Indonesian Journal of International Law 14, no. 2. (2017) https://doi.org/10.17304/ijil.vol14.2.685

Agusman, Damos and Fatihah, Citra Yuda Nur,. “Celebrating the 25th Anniversary of UNCLOS Legal Perspective: The Natuna Case.” Indonesian Journal of International Law 17, no. 4. (2020). https://doi.org/10.17304/ijil.vol17.4.799

Beckman, Robert. “The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea and the Maritime Disputes in the South China Sea.” American Journal of International Law, 107(1), (2013): 142–163. https://doi.org/10.5305/amerjintelaw.107.1.0142

Chinese Society of International Law. “The South China Sea Arbitration Awards: A Critical Study.” Chinese Journal of International Law 17, no. 2, (2018): 207–748. https://doi.org/10.1093/chinesejil/jmy012

Djalal, Hasjim. “Indonesia and the South China Sea Initiative.” Ocean Development &Amp; International Law, 32(2), (2001): 97–103. https://doi.org/10.1080/00908320151100226

Hayton, Bill. “The Modern Origins of China’s South China Sea Claims: Maps, Misunderstandings, and the Maritime Geobody.” Modern China, 45(2), (2019): 127–170. https://doi.org/10.1177/0097700418771678.

HONG, Nong, LI, Jianwei, CHEN, Pingping. The Concept of Archipelagic State and the South China Sea: UNCLOS. State Practice and Implication. China Oceans Law Review 2013, no. 1, (2013).

Majumdar, Munmun. “Beijing Raising the Ante in the Natunas: The Next Flash Point in the South China Sea?. India Quarterly: A Journal of International Affairs 77, no. 3, (2021): 462–478. https://doi.org/10.1177/09749284211027249

Zhao, Suisheng. “East Asian Disorder: China and the South China Sea Disputes.” Asian Survey 60, no. 3, (2020): pp. 490–509. Accessed 26 June 2023, https://online.ucpress.edu/as/article/60/3/490/110498/East-Asian-DisorderChina-and-the-South-China-Sea

Thao, Nguyễn Hồng. “South China Sea: Battle of the Diplomatic Notes among China and Non-Claimant States”, Asia-Pacific Journal of Ocean Law and Policy 8. (2023).

iv) Web Sources

Ogen/Suharto. 3 February 2023. “Indonesia to build naval base combat command in natuna”. Antara News. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://en.antaranews.com/news/162640/indonesia-to-build-naval-base-combat-command-in-natuna

ASEAN Outlook on Indo-pacific. June 2019. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://asean.org/asean2020/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/ASEAN-Outlook-on-the-Indo-Pacific_FINAL_22062019.pdf

ASEAN statement. 26 June 2020. Chairman’s Statements of the 36th ASEAN Summit: Cohesive and Responsive ASEAN, accessed 27 June 2023, https://asean.org/chairmans-statement-of-the-36th-asean-summit-26-june-2020-cohesive-and-responsive-asean/

ASEAN-China Statement. 22 November 2019. https://asean.org/joint-statement-of-the-asean-china-special-summit-to-commemorate-the-30th-anniversary-of-asean-china-dialogue-relations-comprehensive-strategic-partnership-for-peace-security-prosperity-and-sustain/

Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative. 12 November 2021. "Nervous Energy: China Targets New Indonesian, Malaysian Drilling". Accessed 28 June 2023, https://amti.csis.org/nervous-energy-china-targets-new-indonesian-malaysian-drilling/

Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative. 28 March 2023. “(Almost) Everyone is drilling inside the nine-dash line”. Access 28 June 2023, https://amti.csis.org/almost-everyone-is-drilling-inside-the-nine-dash-line/#:~:text=China's%20military%2C%20law%20enforcement%2C%20and,in%20the%20South%20China%20Sea.

Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative. 30 January 2020. "Gone Fishing: Tracking China’s Flotilla from Brunei to Indonesia". Accessed 28 June 2023, https://amti.csis.org/gone-fishing-tracking-chinas-flotilla-from-brunei-to-indonesia/

Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative. 30 March 2023. “Perilous Prospects, Tensions Flare at Malaysian, Vietnamese Oil and Gas Fields. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://amti.csis.org/perilous-prospects-tensions-flare-at-malaysian-vietnamese-oil-and-gas-fields/#:~:text=Perilous%20Prospects%3A%20Tensions%20Flare%20at%20Malaysian%2C%20Vietnamese%20Oil%20and%20Gas%20Fields,-Published%3A%20March%2030&text=China%20Coast%20Guard%20patrols%20near,incidents%20over%20the%20last%20month.

Benar News and RFA Staff. 5 January 2023. China’s coast guard patrols site of Indonesian gas field. Accessed 13 June 2023, https://www.benarnews.org/english/news/indonesian/china-patrols-indonesian-gas-field-01052023032353.html

Cheng, Hanping. 4 August 2020. Indonesia should make comprehensive considerations on the South China Sea. Global Times. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1196714.shtml

Dang, Duan. 18 September 2021. What is happening in Indonesia’s Natuna Sea?. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://scsbrief.substack.com/p/what-is-happening-in-indonesias-natuna

Dang, Duan. 19 September 2021. How did Indonesia respond to China’s incursion into the Natuna Sea?. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://scsbrief.substack.com/p/how-did-indonesia-respond-to-chinas

Duang Dang. 9 October 2021. South China Sea Brief. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://scsbrief.substack.com/p/south-china-sea-brief-october-09;

Duo, Ding. 15 January 2020. China and Indonesia can find common ground over a shared interest: fishing. South China Morning Post. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy/article/3046073/china-and-indonesia-can-find-common-ground-over-shared

ECNS.org. Indonesia reportedly renames EEZ in South China Sea. 15 July 2017. Accessed 29 June 2023, https://www.ecns.cn/2017/07-15/265496.shtml

Evans, Damon. 19 November 2021. “Harbour strikes gas after successfully wrapping up Tuna drilling amid South China Sea spat - News for the Energy Sector”. Energy Voice. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.energyvoice.com/oilandgas/asia/365700/harbour-strikes-gas-after-successfully-wrapping-up-tuna-drilling-amid-south-china-sea-spat/

FPCI. 12 June 2019. Foreign Policy Tapes - Wawancara Prof. Hasjim Djalal tentang Laut Tiongkok Selatan / Interview with Prof. Hasjim Djalal on South China Sea / [Video]. YouTube. Accessed on 29 June 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f9Lh0DF5JtM

Fravel, M. Taylor. 11 July 2016. Traditional Fishing Grounds and China’s Historic Rights Claims in the South China Sea. The National Bureau of Asian Research (NBR). Accessed on 27 June 2023, https://www.nbr.org/publication/traditional-fishing-grounds-and-chinas-historic-rights-claims-in-the-south-china-sea/

Gertz, Bill. 21 September 2017. Beijing Adopts New Tactic for S. China Sea Claims. Washington Free Beacon. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://freebeacon.com/national-security/beijing-adopts-new-tactic-s-china-sea-claims/

Government of China. July 2016. White Paper: China Adheres to the Position of Settling Through Negotiation the Relevant Disputes Between China and the Philippines in the South China Sea. Accessed 17 June 2023, https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/world/2016-07/13/content_26075050.htm

Government of China. 7 December 2014. Position Paper of the Government of the People’s Republic of China on the Matter of Jurisdiction in the South China Sea Arbitration Initiated by the Republic of the Philippines. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/wjdt_665385/2649_665393/201412/t20141207_679387.html

Guilfoyle, Douglas. 25 May 2018. A new twist in the South China Sea Arbitration: The Chinese Society of International Law’s Critical Study. EJILTALK. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.ejiltalk.org/a-new-twist-in-the-south-china-sea-arbitration-the-chinese-society-of-international-laws-critical-study/

Heydarian, Richard. 29 March 2021. How Jokowi bested China, while Duterte ended up a lackey. Nikkei Asia. Accessed 13 June 2023, https://asia.nikkei.com/Opinion/How-Jokowi-bested-China-while-Duterte-ended-up-a-lackey

https://www.mofa.gov.tw/Upload/WebArchive/1989/Position%20Paper%20on%20ROC%20South%20China%20Sea%20Policy%20(illustrated%20pamphlet%20PDF).pdf

Hunt, Katie. 22 March 2016. South China Sea: Indonesia issues protest to China. CNN. Accessed 25 June 2023, https://edition.cnn.com/2016/03/21/asia/indonesia-china-south-china-sea/index.html

Huyen, Quach Thi. 26 November 2020. The ‘Four-Sha’ Claim: Signaling a Post Covid-19 Global Order, Maritime Issue. Accessed 27 June 2023, http://www.maritimeissues.com/law/the-foursha-claim-signalling-a-post-covid19-global-order.html.

Karalekas, Dean. 24 June 2022. Dashing Lines and Faking History: The Complicated History of Taipei’s Maritime Claims. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.e-ir.info/2022/06/24/dashing-lines-and-faking-history-the-complicated-history-of-taipeis-maritime-claims/

Karalekas, Dean, “Dashing Lines and Faking History: The Complicated History of Taipei’s Maritime Claims”, in Asian Territorial and Maritime Disputes, A Critical Introduction, edited by Moises de Souza, Gregory Coutaz & Dean Karalekas, 138 – 157. E-International Relations, 2022.

Ku, Julian & Mirasola, Chris. 31 October 2019. The South China Sea and China’s “Four Sha” Claim: New Legal Theory. Lawfare. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.lawfareblog.com/south-china-sea-and-chinas-four-sha-claim-new-legal-theory-same-bad-argument

Lanh Anh, Nguyen Ti. The ‘Four-Sha’ Claim: Signaling a Post Covid-19 Global Order. Maritime Issue. (2020). http://www.maritimeissues.com/law/the-foursha-claim-signalling-a-post-covid19-global-order.html

Liu, Fu-Kuo., & Spangler, Jonathan. South China Sea Lawfare: Legal Perspectives and International Responses to the Philippines v. China Arbitration Case. South China Sea Think Tank. (2016).

Maritime Awareness Project. 2013. Incident Timeline: South and East China Seas. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://map.nbr.org/interactive/incident-timeline/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Republic of China. 21 March 2016. Position Paper on ROC South China Sea. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://ws.mofa.gov.tw/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 12 July 2016. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 19 June 2016. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 2 January 2020. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed on 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 21 March 2016. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed on 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 22 March 2016. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 29 May 2016. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 30 December 2019. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 6 July 2016. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 28 June 2023, Accessed on 28 June 2023, https://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 2 January 2020. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 27 June 2023, ttps://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China. 7 January 2020. Regular Press Briefing. Accessed 27 June 2023, ttps://www.Fmprc.gov.cn/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. 1 January 2020. Press Release. Accessed on 25 June 2023, https://kemlu.go.id/portal/id/read/933/siaran_pers/ri-kembali-tegaskan-tolak-klaim-unilateral-rrt-atas-zee-indonesia

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Indonesia. 7 January 2016. Annual Press Statement of The Minister For Foreign Affairs of The Republic of Indonesia. Accessed 26 June 2023, https://kemlu.go.id/portal/id/read/756/pidato/pernyataan-pers-tahunan-menteri-luar-negeri-ri-tahun-2016

Pearson, James and Gloystein, Henning, “Vietnam halts South China Sea oil drilling project under pressure from Beijing”, Reuter 23 March 2018. Accessed 287 June 2023, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-southchinasea-vietnam-idUSKBN1GZ0JN

Sourabh, Gupta. 11 January 2020. Jakarta should not dismiss Beijing’s “historic rights” claim. The Jakarta Post. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.thejakartapost.com/academia/2020/01/11/jakarta-should-not-dismiss-beijings-historic-rights-claim.html

Strangio, Sebastian. 2 December 2021. China Demanded Halt to Indonesian Drilling Near Natuna Islands: Report, the Diplomat. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://thediplomat.com/2021/12/china-demanded-halt-to-indonesian-drilling-near-natuna-islands-report/

Sulaiman, Yohanes. 13 January 2020. Why Indonesia keeps sending mixed signals on the Natuna sea dispute with China. The Conversation. Accessed 13 June 2023, https://theconversation.com/why-indonesia-keeps-sending-mixed-signals-on-the-natuna-sea-dispute-with-china-129562

Thayer, Carlyle Alan. 19 November 2021. China Coast Guard Lurking in Indonesian Waters. Thayer Consultancy Background Brief. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.scribd.com/document/521046405/Thayer-China-Coast-Guard-Lurking-in-Indonesian-Waters

United Nations Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf (UN CLCS). 8 July 2010. Communication of the Republic of Indonesia. Accessed on 28 June 2023, https://www.un.org/depts/los/clcs_new/submissions_files/mysvnm33_09/idn_2010re_mys_vnm_e.pdf

Valencia, Mark J. 24 January 2020. China-Indonesia South China Sea incident likely a blip in a long-term trend of mutual adjustment. ASEAN Toda. Accessed 28 June 2023, https://www.aseantoday.com/2020/01/china-indonesia-south-china-sea-incident-likely-a-blip-in-a-long-term-trend-of-mutual-adjustment/

Weatherbee, Donald E. “Re-Assessing Indonesia’s Role in the South China Sea.” ISEAS Perspective 2016 no. 18. (2016). Accessed 26 June 2023, https://www.iseas.edu.sg/images/pdf/ISEAS_Perspective_2016_18.pdf

Xiaolu, Lei. 11 March 2020. Who can fish in waters near Natuna Islands and how? The Jakarta Post. Accessed 27 June 2023, https://www.thejakartapost.com

Xin, Liu. 15 July 2017. Indonesia reportedly renames EEZ in South China Sea. Global Times. Accessed on 28 June 2023, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-07-15/south-china-sea-territory-renamed-by-indonesia/8711346

Ying, Fu., & Shicun, Wu. 10 May 2016. South China Sea: How We Got to This Stage. The National Interest. https://nationalinterest.org/feature/south-china-sea-how-we-got-stage-16118?nopaging=1

v) Other sources

Chairman’s Statements of the 36th ASEAN Summit: Cohesive and Responsive ASEAN, 26 June 2020.

Dumoli Agusman, Damos. Kompas, 22 November 2015.

Keyuan, Zou. 18-20 January 2016. Presentation at 2nd Conference on Finding a Resolution on the Issue on the South China Sea, organized by CSIS-Indonesia and NISCS, Hoiko, Hainan.

Kompas. 5 February 1974.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia, Treaty Room. https://treaty.kemlu.go.id/

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. 1 March 2016. Diplomatic Protest Note. On file with Author.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. 10 November 2020. Aide Memoire on CCG Law. On file with Author.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. 16 July 1996. Aide Memoire. On file with Author.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. 2000. White Paper (internal) on Natuna. On file with Author.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. 29 May 2003. Internal Notes. On file with Author.

The Strait Times. 27 June 1995. No problem with China over Natuna Isles, says Alatas

****

Download

Share

COinS