•  
  •  
 

Trend of Non-Pharmacological Therapy for First Phase of Active Labor Pain: A Pilot Study

Abstract

There are several of non-pharmacological therapies to be used as caring practice to mother with labor pain. This study aimed to observe the effectiveness of both single and combination therapy of warm compresses and counter pressure massage (CPM) for the management of labor pain during the first active phase through medical records. This is a pilot study that used a cohort prospective design. The total number of respondents was 90 respondents, divided into 3 groups based on the non-pharmacological therapy that was given by the midwives or nurses. Pain level was measured with NRS 11. The study was conducted at PKU Muhammadiyah Gamping Hospital from May 2020 to September 2020. A comparative hypothesis analysis was done to compare the Pretest-Posttest of pain level between groups using the Wilcoxon, Kruskal-Wallis, and Post hoc Mann-Whitney tests with a significance of p <0.05. There was a reduction of 1.53 pain level of subject who received CPM, 1.16 by received warm compress and 1.67 for those who received combination therapy. It was found there was a significant difference between three groups with p=0.020. It was found that CPM was compared to Warm compress obtained p=0.017, CPM compared to Combination therapy obtained p=0.019, warm compress compared to combination therapy obtained p = 0.396.Combination therapy showed the highest reduction effect toward pain level of First Phase of Active Labor Pain. However, the CPM therapy showed to achieve effectiveness compared to warm compress and combination therapy.

References

1. Behdad S, Abdollahi M, Ayatollahi V, Hajiesmaeili MR, ShamsiHM, Heiranizadeh N et al. The Effect of Administering WarmedIntravenous Fluids on Maternal Body Core Temperature inCesarean Delivery. 2012. 2. Farida S, Sulistiyanti A. Metode Counterpressure Sebagai UpayaUntuk Mengurangi Nyeri Persalinan Kala I. Smiknas 2019; :217–222. 3. Rahmawati L, Ningsih MP. Efektifitas Teknik Counter PressureDan Abdominal Lifting Terhadap Pengurangan Rasa NyeriPada Ibu Bersalin Kala I Fase Aktif Di Bpm Kota Padang. J MedMedia Inf Kesehat 2019; 6: 217–224. 4. Latifah L, Setiawati N, Rismawati I. Are there any effects oftapping therapy in reducing anxiety and labor pain in thelatent phase? Ann Trop Med Public Health 2019; 22.doi:10.36295/ASRO.2019.221152. 5. Pramudianti DN. Literature Review/ : Non pharmacologicalMethods to Reduce Pain in The First Stage of Labor with aCounter Pressure Technique. Health MEDIA 2020; 1: 6–11. 6. Sari N, Runjati, Fatmasari D, Pujiyanto TI. Practices ofCounter Pressure and Birth Ball Exercise Combination toIncrease â-Endorphin Hormone Levels in Labor Pain. Proc1st Int Conf Sci Health Econ Educ Technol ICoSHEET 20192020; 27: 314–317. 7. Sadat HZ, Forugh F, Maryam H, Nosratollah MN, Hosein S.The impact of manual massage on intensity and duration ofpain at first phase of labor in primigravid women. Int J MedRes 2016; 1: 16–18. 8. Cahyawati FE, Listyaningrum TH, Gunadi A. CounterPressure Massage And Warm Compress Combination AsNon-Pharmacological Therapy Of Anxiety In Labor InactivePhase 1. J Ilm Bidan 2021; 5.https://e-journal.ibi.or.id/index.php/jib/article/view/268 (accessed 24 Jun2022). 9. Puspita D, Jannatun N, Johan I. The Influence of MassageCounterpressure on Pain Rate Reduction in First Stage ActivePhase Labor Process. 2nd Jt Int Conf 2013; : 214–218. 10. Akbarzadeh M, Nematollahi A, Farahmand M, Amooee S.The Effect of Two-Staged Warm Compress on the PainDuration of First and Second Labor Stages and Apgar Scorein Prim Gravida Women: a Randomized Clinical Trial. JCaring Sci 2018; 7: 21–26. 11. Farahmand M, Khooshab E, Hasanzadeh F, Amooee S,Akbarzadeh M. The effect of warm compress Bi-stage onpain strength in labor stages and after delivery. Int J WomensHealth Reprod Sci 2020; 8: 46–52. 12. Kaur J, Sheoran P, Kaur S, Sarin J. Effectiveness of WarmCompression on Lumbo-Sacral Region in Terms of LabourPain Intensity and Labour Outcomes among Nulliparous:an Interventional Study. J Caring Sci 2020; 9: 9–12. 13. Juwita L. Literature Review: Pengaruh Massage TherapyTerhadap Nyeri Persalinan Kala Satu. J Ners Lentera 2019; 7:114–129. 14. Mukhoirotin, Kurniawati, Fatmawati DA. The influence ofslow back stroke massage, cold-compress and warmcompress to the level of prostaglandin f2á (Pgf2á) in primarydysmenorrhea. Indian J Forensic Med Toxicol 2020; 14:1364–1369. 15. Abdallah Sayed HE, Abd Alhamid Attit Allah N. Effect ofLocalized Warm versus Cold Compresses on Pain Severityduring First Stage of Labor among Primiparous. J Nurs HealthSci 2019; 8: 14–24. 16. Ibrahim HA-F, Elgzar WI, Hassan HE. Effect of WarmCompresses Versus Lubricated Massage during the SecondStage of Labor on Perineal Outcomes among PrimiparousWomen. J Nurs Health Sci 2017; 6: 64–76. 17. Fitria CTN, Runjati R, Patriajati S, Anwar C. Innovationrelaxation belts to reduce labor pain itensity and increase â-endoprhine levels. Medisains 2020; 18: 69–69. 18. Susiloningtyas L, Novitasari F, Wulandari RF. Effect of HeatCompresses Hydrotherapy to Reduction of Pain Labor Stage1st. Str J Ilm Kesehat 2019; 8: 136–145. 19. Morikawa M, Sekizuka-kagami N, Tabuchi N. Comparisonof lumbar hot compresses and lumbar massage on laborpain-alleviating effects during the first stage of labor. J NursSci Eng 2020; 7: 25–32. 20. Widiastuti W, Peristiowati Y, Farida S. Effect of LargeCompress Aroma Lavender Therapy to Intensity Scale andOld Labor of I there are Active Phase Until Second Stage in Primigravida Mother in the Region Puskesmas Pagak DistrictMalang. J Qual Public Health 2018; 2: 25–29. 21. Sreechithra C. Effectiveness of Acupressure and WarmCompress on Labour Pain During First Stage of LabourAmong Primigravidae Mothers Effectiveness of Acupressureand Warm Compress on Labour Pain During First Stage ofLabour Among. Disertatation - Tamil Nadi Med Univ MasterSci Nurs Program 2016.http://repository-tnmgrmu.ac.in/3213/1/3003283301423152SreechithraC.pdf. 22. Zurahmi MHJ. Warm compresses Against Pain Giving BirthIn Practice Independent. J Nurs Midwifery 2019; 2: 119–122. 23. Oktriani T, Ermawati E, Bachtiar H. The Difference Of PainLabour Level With Counter Pressure And Abdominal LiftingOn Primigravida In Active Phase of First Stage Labor. JMidwifery 2018; 3: 45–45. 24. Purwaningsih eka. Preventif/ : Jurnal KesehatanMasyarakat the Effect of Masase Counterpressure on LaborPain Kala One Active Phase in Mother Birds in Bpm Setia.Prev J Kesehat Masy Vol 2018; 9: 62–66. 25. Juniartati E, Widyawati MN. Literature Review/ : PenerapanCounter Pressure Untuk Mengurangi Nyeri Persalinan KalaI. J Kebidanan 2018; 8: 112–112. 26. Pramudianti DN. Literature Review/ : Non pharmacologicalMethods to Reduce Pain in The First Stage of Labor with aCounter Pressure Technique. Health MEDIA 2020; 1: 6–11. 27. Santiasari RN, Nurdiati DS, Lismidiati W, Saudah N.Effectiveness of Effleurage and Counter-Pressure Massagesin Reducing Labor Pain. Humanist Netw Sci Technol 2018; 2:2016–2019. 28. Daiyah I. Keefektifan Counter Preassure Massage terhadapIntensitas Nyeri Kala I Fase Aktif Persalinan di PuskesmasRawat Inap Langgam Kabupaten Pelalawan Impact of CounterPreassure Massage on Intensity of Pain in Active Phase ofThe First Stage Labor at Langgam I. EMBRIO J Kebidanan2020; 12: 1–9. 29. Darmawan FH, Waslia D. Endorphin Massage and EffleurageMassage as a Management of Labour Pain on The ActiveFirst Stage of Primigravida at Independent Midwife Practicein Cimahi. Third Int Semin Glob Health 2019; 3: 45–51. 30. Yuliawati Y. Efek Kombinasi Counterpressure dan PelvicRocking terhadap Penurunan Intensitas Nyeri PersalinanNormal Kala I Fase Aktif. J Kesehat Metro Sai Wawai 2019;12: 33–39.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS