•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Previous studies treated ships as objects by examining their relationships to economic activities, cultural manifestations, and historical records. However, few studies sought to understand the personal significance of ships for people working and living at sea. This paper views ships as a space of fractal distinctions, in which the public-private divide can be applied without a fixed boundary. It extends Susan Gal’s theory of the public and the private by analysing the cultural metaphor that anchors those two notions. Based on ten months of ethnographic fieldwork in Probolinggo, this paper delineates how “emotional space” becomes a cultural metaphor when ships sail on the sea. Meanwhile, it becomes a “gendered space” when docked on land. This variance derives from a broader cultural context in which men working at sea differentiate themselves from those living on land, allowing the ship to serve as a space of comfort and a source of pride.

References

Abd. Rahman, Hamid. 2016. “Binongko people‘s life in Coral Island”, Wacana, Journal of the Humanities of Indonesia Vol. 17 No. 1: 19-37. 

Austin, J.L. 2020. How to do things with words. London: Barakaldo Books. 

Butler, Judith. 2016. Notes toward a performative theory of assembly. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 

Chandra, Nuraini. 2016. “The intangible legacy of the Indonesian Bajo”, Wacana, Journal of the Humanities of Indonesia Vol. 17 No. 1: 1-18. 

Fox, James, Dedi S. Adhuri, Gerzon Tom Therik, and Michelle Ann Carnegie. 2009. “Searching for a livelihood; The dilemma of small-boat fishermen in Eastern Indonesia”, in: Budi Resosudarmo and Frank Jotzo (ed.), Working with nature against poverty, pp. 201-225. Canberra: Indonesia Project The Australian National University. 

Gal, Susan. 2002. “A semiotics of the public/private distinction”, Differences (Bloomington, Ind.) 13: 77-95. 

Gal, Susan. 2005. “Language ideologies compared; Metaphors of public/ private”, Journal of linguistic anthropology 15: 23-37. 

Gunawan, Bambang Indratno. 2016. “The diversity of fisheries-based livelihoods in the Berau Delta, East Kalimantan”, Wacana, Journal of the Humanities of Indonesia Vol. 17 No.1: 68-96. 

Iqbal, Muhammad, Momchil Terziev, Tahsin Tezdogan, and Atilla Incecik. 2023. “Operability analysis of traditional small fishing boats in Indonesia with different loading conditions”, Ships and Offshore Structures 18: 1060- 1079. 

Izzudin, Muhammad. 2024. “Fishery livelihood adaptation on climate change; A bibliometric analysis and review”, in: Ramayda Akmal, Iping Liang, Vincenz Serrano, Wulan Tri Astuti, Raymon D. Ritumban, and Ari Bagus Panuntun (eds), Proceedings of the Critical Island Studies 2023 Conference (CISC 2023). France: Atlantis Press (Zeger Karssen). 

Jonge, Huub de. 1989. Madura dalam empat zaman, pedagang, perkembangan ekonomi dan Islam; Suatu studi antropologi ekonomi. Jakarta: Koninklijk Instituut voor Taal, Land- en Volkenkunde (KITLV) Jakarta, Lembaga Ilmu Pengetahuan Indonesia (LIPI), and Gramedia. 

Kuntowijoyo. 2017. Perubahan sosial dalam masyarakat agraris Madura, 1850-1940. Jakarta: Matabangsa, Yayasan Adikarya IKAPI, and the Ford Foundation. 

Jonge, Huub de. 1989. Madura dalam empat zaman, pedagang, perkembangan ekonomi dan Islam; Suatu studi antropologi ekonomi. Jakarta: Koninklijk Instituut voor Taal, Land- en Volkenkunde (KITLV) Jakarta, Lembaga Ilmu Pengetahuan Indonesia (LIPI), and Gramedia. 

Kuntowijoyo. 2017. Perubahan sosial dalam masyarakat agraris Madura, 1850-1940. Jakarta: Matabangsa, Yayasan Adikarya IKAPI, and the Ford Foundation. 

Lekkerkerker, J.G.W. 1931. Probolinggo, geschiedenis en overlevering; Uit officieele publicaties. Amsterdam: J.H. de Bussy. 

Low, Setha. 2016. Spatializing culture; The ethnography of space and place. First edition. Routledge. [DOI: 10.4324/9781315671277.] 

Lynch, Melody and Sarah Turner. 2022. “Rocking the boat; Intersectional resistance to marine conservation policies in Wakatobi National Park, Indonesia”, Gender, Place and Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography 29: 1376-1398. 

Niehof, Anke. 1986. Women and fertility in Madura (Indonesia). PhD thesis, Leiden University. 

Mahmood, Saba. 2011. Politics of piety; The Islamic revival and the feminist subject. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. 

Mudjijono and Hery Priswanto. 2024. “Fishing boat manufacturing technology is a love attraction for the maritime region”, in: Ramayda Akmal, Iping Liang, Vincenz Serrano, Wulan Tri Astuti, Raymon D. Ritumban, and Ari Bagus Panuntun (eds), Proceedings of the Critical Island Studies 2023 Conference (CISC 2023). France: Atlantis Press (Zeger Karssen). 

O‘Connor, Sue, Shimona Kealy, Lucas Wattimena, Adam Black, Muhammad Husni, and Mahirta. 2023. “Sailing the deep blue sea; The rock art of 

Wetang Island, Maluku Barat Daya, Indonesia”, Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology 18: 398-425. 

Pelling, Karina. 2025. Tapal Kuda - Eastern Salient of Java. Canberra: CartoGIS Services Australian National University. 

Probolinggo, Setda. 2010. Sejarah Kota Probolinggo dari waktu ke waktu. Probolinggo: Bagian Humas dan Protokol. 

Rahman, Ilham Nur, Ilham Andriyanto, Hanieke Syahla, Abdila, Mia Fadilah, and Aprillia Firmonasari. 2024. “Rejang tribe ethnobotany index; Shifting, inheritance, and local knowledge conservation strategy towards food security in Indonesia”, in: Ramayda Akmal, Iping Liang, Vincenz Serrano, Wulan Tri Astuti, Raymon D. Ritumban, and Ari Bagus Panuntun (eds), Proceedings of the Critical Island Studies 2023 Conference (CISC 2023). France: Atlantis Press (Zeger Karssen). 

Retsikas, Konstantinos. 2012. Becoming - An Anthropological approach to understandings of the person in Java. London: Anthem Press. [DOI: 10.7135/ UPO9780857285317.] 

Riskianingrum, Devi, Yuda B Tangkilisan, Bondan Kanumoyoso, and Herry Yogaswara. 2024. “Risk culture on Sebesi Island; Examining the interplay of nature and culture from 1883 to 2018”, in Ramayda Akmal, Iping Liang, Vincenz Serrano, Wulan Tri Astuti, Raymon D. Ritumban, and Ari Bagus Panuntun (eds), Proceedings of the Critical Island Studies 2023 Conference (CISC 2023). France: Atlantis Press (Zeger Karssen). 

Schneider, Katharina. 2018. “Precariousness and prosperity among Javanese fish traders”, HAU Journal of Ethnographic Theory 8: 640-655. 

Stewart, Kathleen. 2007. Ordinary affects. New York, NY: Duke University Press. 

Yoga, Adwidya, Noor Diana Arrasyid, and Erma Estiana. 2024. “Paradox in coastal area; Capitalism in hotels and resorts development”, in: Ramayda Akmal, Iping Liang, Vincenz Serrano, Wulan Tri Astuti, Raymon D. Ritumban, and Ari Bagus Panuntun (eds), Proceedings of the Critical Island Studies 2023 Conference (CISC 2023). France: Atlantis Press Zeger Karssen. 

Interviews 

Interview with Ari, Probolinggo, 29-3-2024. 

Interview with Narmo, Probolinggo, 11-3-2024. 

Interview with Representative of Museum Kota Probolinggo, 31-07-2024. 

Interview with Sadi, Probolinggo, 10-3-2024.

Share

COinS