•  
  •  
 

Abstract

This article presents brief life stories of select Indonesians who were forced into exile by the Suharto regime after the 1965 National Tragedy in Indonesia. It focuses on staunch nationalist exiles who were rendered stateless by the self-proclaimed “New Order“ for refusing to accept the overthrow of President Sukarno and declare loyalty to the military regime. Faced with a life in exile, they sought refuge in the former colonial nation of the Netherlands. After exploring a brief history of exile in the bilateral relationship, it explores the choices made by select individuals who moved to the Netherlands from a variety of other locations of initial refuge. It then explores the frameworks of support which bolster the exiles’ sense of identity as Indonesian (trans)nationalists who reside in the Netherlands, before finally locating the experiences of the exiles in the context of their changing engagement with their homeland.

References

Acton, Lord. 1967. Essays in the liberal interpretation of history. Chicago, IL and London: University of Chicago Press.

Affan, Heyder. 2021. “G30S: ‘Saya selalu berdoa, kapan bertemu ibu’, kisah Francisca Fanggidaej dan tujuh anaknya ‘terpisah’ 38 tahun sejak 1965”, BBC News Indonesia. Jakarta: BBC News. [Available at: https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/indonesia-58634801; sighted 25-5-2022.]

Aleida, Martin. 2017. Tanah air yang hilang; Wawancara dengan orang-orang “klayaban” di Eropa. Jakarta: Penerbit Buku Kompas.

Alham, Asahan, Mawie Ananta Jonie, A. Kohar Ibrahim, Cama Ella Bouwman, Sobron Aidit, and Hersri Setiawan (eds). 2002. Di negeri orang; Puisi penyair Indonesia eksil. Jakarta: Amanah – Lontar.

Anderson, Benedict R. O’Gorman. 1992. Long-distance nationalism; World capitalism and the rise of identityp politics. Amsterdam: The Wertheim Lecture, CASA – Centre for Asian Studies Amsterdam.

Anon. 2015. “Djawoto”. [Retrieved from: https://web.archive.org/web/20150114062236/; http://www.jakarta.go.id/eng/encyclopedia/detail/410; accessed on: 29-4-2022.]

Aziiz, Abdul Ghani 2020. “Indonesian exiles in the Czech Republic”. Bachelors degree thesis, Palacky University, Olomouc.

Budiman, Kuslan. 2008. “Interview”. [With David T. Hill, 18-11-2008, Woerden, Netherlands.]

Chambert-Loir, Henri. 2016a. “Bibliography of exile literature (Sastra eksil)”, Archipel 91: 177-183.

Chambert-Loir, Henri. 2016b. “Locked out; Literature of the Indonesian exiles post-1965“, Archipel 91: 119-145.

Chambert-Loir, Henri. 2017. “PKI Stroganoff; Leila Chudori’s Novel Pulang (Revisited)”, in: Jan van der Putten, Monika Arnez, Edwin P. Wieringa, and Arndt Graf (eds), Traditions redirecting contemporary Indonesian cultural productions, pp. 67-98. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

Daraini, Ibnu Nadzir. 2017. “Imagining the homeland; The use of the Internet among Indonesian exiles in the Netherlands”. Masters thesis, Universiteit van Amsterdam.

Desweriel, Modelia Novinta. 2021. “How Indonesian exiles in the Czech Republic understand their statelessness and eventual citizenship”. Masters thesis, Masaryk University, Brno.

Dewansyah, Bilal. 2021. “From ‘political to social’ role; The shifting strategy of Indonesian diaspora movement on development”, in: Ajaya K. Sahoo (ed.), Routledge Handbook of Asian Diaspora and Development, pp. 288-300. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

Dragojlovic, Ana. 2010. “‘Sukarno’s students’; Reconfiguring notions of exile, community and remembering”, Review of Indonesian and Malaysian Affairs, 44: 53-83.

Dragojlovic, Ana. 2016. Beyond Bali; Subaltern citizens and post-colonial intimacy. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.

Faist, Thomas and Basak Bilecen. 2019. “Transnationalism”, in: Steven J. Gold and Stephanie J. Nawyn (eds), Routledge International Handbook of Migration Studies, pp. 499-511. London: Routledge.

Fakih, Farabi. 2020. Authoritarian modernization in Indonesia’s early independence period; The foundation of the new order state (1950-1965). Leiden and Boston, NY: Brill.

Fanggidaej, Francisca and Hersri Setiawan. 2006. Memoar perempuan revolusioner Francisca Fanggidaej. Yogyakarta: Galang Press.

Foulcher, Keith. 1986. Social commitment in literature and the arts; the Indonesian “Institute of People’s Culture” 1950-1965. Clayton: Southeast Asian Studies, Monash University.

Gurning, Agnes Theodora. 2011. “Memory, experience and identity of the Indonesian political exiles of 1965 in the Netherlands”. Master Thesis, Universiteit Utrecht.

Hearman, Vannessa. 2010. “The last men in Havana; Indonesian exiles in Cuba”, Review of Indonesian and Malaysian Affairs 44:1: 83-109.

Heuvel, Aad van den. 2004. “Indonesia; The hidden history of 1965”, (soundcloud recording), in: Writers Unlimited. The Hague. [Retrieved from: https://www.writersunlimited.nl/ en/programme/indonesia-the-hidden-history-of-1965; accessed on: 29-4-2022.]

Hill, David T. 1993. “Basuki Resobowo; Creative energies in exile”, Inside Indonesia 36: 38-41.

Hill, David T. 2010a. “Indonesia’s exiled left as the Cold War thaws”, Review of Indonesian and Malaysian Affairs (RIMA) 44: 21-51.

Hill, David T. 2010b. Journalism and politics in Indonesia; A critical biography of Mochtar Lubis (1922-2004) as editor and author. London and New York, NY: Routledge.

Hill, David T. 2014. “Indonesian political exiles in the USSR”, Critical Asian Studies 46: 621-648.

Hill, David T. 2020. “Cold War polarisation, delegated party authority, and diminishing exilic options; The dilemma of Indonesian political exiles in China after 1965”, Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde (BKI) 176: 338–372.

Hill, David T. 2022. “The Fragile Bloom of the Kimilsungia; Indonesian political exiles in North Korea“, Indonesia and the Malay World. 50: 147, 139-160. [Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/13639811.2022.2026620.]

Imhoff, Evert van and Gijs Beets. 2004. “A demographic history of the Indo-Dutch population, 1930–2001”, Journal of Population Research 21 (March): 47-72.

Isa, Ibrahim. 2014. “Learning from the past; To move forwards along the path of reconciliation, mutual understanding and peace”. [Conference paper in The Netherlands-Japan-Indonesia Dialogue. Amsterdam.]

Isa, Ibrahim. [2000?]. Suara seorang eksil. [Amsterdam?]: Pustaka Pena.

Kitamura, Yumi. 2017. “Long way home; The life history of Chinese-Indonesian migrants in the Netherlands”, Wacana, Journal of the Humanities of Indonesia 18: 24-37.

Kizir, Didem Gül 2021. “The International and the Indonesian Nationalist Movement”. Master thesis, Middle East Technical University, Ankara.

Kraak, J.H. 1958. “The repatriation of the Dutch from Indonesia”, R.E.M.P Bulletin (Research Group from European Migration Problems) 6: 27-40.

Kusuma, Mira Wijaya. 2006. “Mengenang 100 tahun Djawoto”, in: Serikat-Kaum-Terkutuk. Amsterdam: Perhimpunan Dokumentasi Indonesia (Perdoi).

Lukman, Tatiana. 2008. Panta Rhei; Tidak ada pengorbanan yang sia-sia. Air Sungai Digul mengalir terus! Yogyakarta: Pustaka Sempu.

Lukman, Tatiana. 2010. Pelangi. Bandung: Ultimus.

Lukman, Tatiana. 2013. Alternatif. Jakarta: Jaringan Kerja Kebudayaan Rakyat (JAKER).

Lukman, Tatiana. 2016. Trotskyisme? Sosialisme di satu negeri atau revolusi permanen? Yogyakarta: Pustaka Sempu.

Maulana, Syarif. 2021. Nasib manusia; Kisah awal Uzhara, eksil di Rusia. Bandung: Ultimus.

Mayaratih, Yuke. 2015. “Ini kerinduan para eksil tragedi 1965 di HUT RI ke-70”, Tempo. Jakarta: Tempo co. [Available at: https://nasional.tempo.co/read/692550/ini-kerinduan-para-eksil-tragedi-1965-di-hut-ri-ke-70; sighted 5-3-2021.]

Melvin, Jess. 2018. The army and the Indonesian genocide; Mechanics of mass murder. New York, NY: Routledge.

Mintardjo, Sardjio. 2008. “Interview”. [With David T. Hill, 17-11-2008, Oestgeest, the Netherlands.]

Morriën, Joop. 1995. Indonesië liet me nooit meer los; Vijftig jaar antikoloniale strijd. Amsterdam: Uitgave Stichting Indonesië Commissie.

Morriën, Joop. 2000. “’Er is nog maar weinig wezenlijk veranderd’: Interview met Tjipto Munandar” [‘Very little has really changed’: Interview with Tjipto Munandar], in: A.S. Munandar (2009a), Kumpulan tulisan; Pendapat dan pandangan (1990-2009), pp. 274-280. [Den Haag?]: Pembaharu.

Munandar, A.S. 2009a. Kumpulan tulisan; Pendapat dan pandangan (1990-2009). [Den Haag?]: Pembaharu.

Munandar, A.S. 2009b. “Interview”. [With David T. Hill, 26-5-2009, Rotterdam.]

Panggabean, Rosa. 2014. Exile. Jakarta [?]: n.p.

Priyambodo, R.H. 2018. “In memoriam – sastrawan eksil Kuslan Budiman”, ANTARA News 7 December 2018. [Available at: https://www.antaranews.com/berita/775593/in-memoriam-sastrawan-eksil-kuslan-budiman; sighted 18-1-2019.]

Resobowo, Basuki. [1987?]. Bercermin dimuka kaca; Seniman, seni dan masyarakat. [Amsterdam, self-published by author.]

Ricci, Ronit, Anand A. Yang, and Kieko Matteson (eds). 2016. Exile in colonial Asia; Kings, convicts, commemoration. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai’i Press.

Safitri, Yoland Eka. 2021. “Kisah generasi intelektual yang terpaksa menjadi eksil pada Orde Baru”, Lingkar Studi Feminis. [Retrieved from: https://www.lingkarstudifeminis.org/2021/05/kisah-generasi-intelektual-yang.html; accessed on: 17-3-2022.]

Santosa, Teguh. 2010a. “Dari Aneta ke Antara, dari Bucharest, Hanoi hingga terdampar di Amstelveen”, Teguhtimur.com. [Available at: https://teguhtimur.com/2010/ 05/27/dari-aneta-ke-antara-dari-bucharest-hanoi-hingga-terdampar-di-amstelveen/; sighted 30-4-2022.]

Santosa, Teguh. 2010b. “Nuni berharap SBY yang bijaksana berkenan memecahkan perkara tanah bapaknya”. [Available at: https://teguhtimur.com/2010/07/01/nuni-berharap-sby-yang-bijaksana-berkenan-memecahkan-perkara-tanah-bapaknya/; sighted 30-4-2022.]

Saptari, Ratna. 2019. “Persecution through denial of citizenship; Indonesians in forced exile post 1965”, in: S.E. Wieringa, J. Melvin, and A. Pohlman

(eds), The International People’s Tribunal for 1965 and the Indonesian genocide, pp. 115-134. London and New York, NY: Routledge. [First edition.]

Sarmadji. 2008. “Interview”. [With David T. Hill, 8-11-2009, Amsterdam.]

Sarmadji. 2009. “Interview”. [With David T. Hill, 25-5-2009, Amsterdam.]

Sasongko, Angga Dwimas (Director). 2016. Surat dari Praha. [Film.]

Sastra Diredja, Suparna. 1987. Romusa. Amsterdam: Khattulistiwa.

Sastra Diredja, Suparna. 1992. MMC; Di lereng Merapi Merbabu 1948-1949. Amsterdam: Khatulistiwa.

Schiller, Nina Glick. 2005. “Long-distance nationalism”, in: Melvin Ember, Carol R. Ember, and Ian Skoggard (eds), Encyclopedia of diasporas; Immigrant and refugee cultures Around the world, pp. 570-580. Boston, NY: Springer US.

Sinuraya, Sulistiadewi Notoprayitno. 2012. “Interview”. [With David T. Hill, 28-9-2012, Haarlem.]

Sipayung, Bambang Alfred. 2011. “Exiled memories; The collective memory of Indonesian 1965 exiles”. MA thesis, Institute of Social Studies, The Hague.

Solehudin, Rizki. 2017. “Representasi nasionalisme eksil 1965 (Analisis semiotika foto Exile karya Rosa Panggabean)”. Sarjana thesis, Universitas Islam Negeri Syarif Hidayatullah, Jakarta.

Sungkono. 2017. “Transparansi adalah tekanan kuat”, in: Aboeprijadi Santoso, Yanti Mualim, and Lea Pamungkas (eds), Dari beranda tribunal; Bunga rampai kisah relawan, pp. 8-12. Bandung: Friends of International People’s Tribunal 1965 and Ultimus.

Theo, Rika. 2018. Unravelling Indonesian student mobility to China; Politics, identities, and trajectories. PhD thesis, Utrecht University.

Triyana, Bonnie. 2007. “Soeraedi Tahsin Sandjadirdja; Tokoh pers nasional asal Banten yang terlupakan”, Lumbung Banten; Pusat Dokumentasi Pusaka Banten. [Available at: https://lumbungbanten.wordpress.com/2007/10/20/soeraedi-tahsin-sandjadirdja-tokoh-pers-nasional-asal-banten-yang-terlupakan/; sighted 30-3-2022.]

Vertovec, Steven. 2009. Transnationalism. London: Routledge.

Wahid, Abdurrahman. 2000. “Instruksi Presiden Republik Indonesia Nomor 1 Tahun 2000 tentang permasalahan orang-orang Indonesia yang berada di luar negeri dan terhalang pulang ke tanah air sejak terjadinya peristiwa G 30 S/PKI”, Instruksi Presiden Republik Indonesia. [Retrieved from: https://www.hukumonline.com/pusatdata/viewfile/lt556557f109fc9/parent/lt5565578c5e0b7; accessed on: 2-3-2022.]

Ward, Kerry 2008. Networks of empire; Forced migration in the Dutch East India Company. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Zhou, Taomo. 2013. Ambivalent alliance; Chinese policy towards Indonesia, 1960-1965. Washington DC: Cold War International History Project.

Zhou, Taomo. 2019a. “Global reporting from the Third World; The Afro-Asian journalists’ Association, 1963-1974”, Critical Asian Studies 51(2): 166-197.

Zhou, Taomo. 2019b. Migration in the time of revolution; China, Indonesia, and the Cold War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Download

Share

COinS