Journal of Materials Exploration and Findings
Abstract
The susceptibility of steam line pipes, especially in the HAZ (heat-affected zone) and weldment areas, to hydrogen sulfide in the geothermal industry is crucial to understand from the early stages, particularly during construction. The combination of tensile stress from residual stresses after welding and metallurgical phase transformation makes the joint areas vulnerable to sulfide stress cracking. This condition becomes even more extreme when the equipment operates during the well stimulation phase. This research assesses the severity of H₂S-induced cracking using NACE MR0175 and ISO 15156-1 standards, focusing on the effects of pH and partial pressure of H₂S (pH₂S). The findings aim to provide insights into critical factors influencing H₂S cracking susceptibility and to enhance material integrity in geothermal systems. The result shows that while A106 Gr B steel generally meets sour service requirements, certain nodes within the geothermal facility exhibit a moderate risk of cracking under transient conditions. These results emphasize the importance of controlling fluid composition and implementing proper welding procedures to mitigate sulfide stress cracking (SSC).
References
American Petroleum Institute 2020, Damage mechanisms affecting fixed equipment in the refining industry. THIRD. USA: API Publishing Services.
ESDM, K 2020, Potensi Pengembangan Energi Panas Bumi di Indonesia. Available at: https://ebtke.esdm.go.id/lintas/id/investasi-ebtke/sektor-panas-bumi/potensi#:~:text=Berada di kawasan ring of,diperkirakan mencapai 23%2C7 GW.
Grimes, W D, Miglin, B P, French, R N, Gonzalez, M A & Chambers, B D 2014, 'The Physical Chemistry Nature of Hydrogen Sulfide Gas as It Affects Sulfide Stress Crack Propagation in Steel,' in NACE CORROSION 2014, pp. NACE-2014.
Grimes, W D, Wilms, M E & Chambers, B D 2015, 'Conservatism in Sour Testing with Hydrogen Sulfide Partial Pressure Exposures–Towards a More Consistent Approach,' in NACE CORROSION 2015, pp. NACE-2015.
Hartoyo, F, Irianti, G P, Fatriansyah, J F, Ovelia, H, Mas' ud, I A, Digita, F R, Fauzi, A & Anis, M 2023, ‘Weibull distribution optimization for piping risk calculation due to uniform corrosion using Monte Carlo method,’ Materials Today: Proceedings, vol. 80, pp.1650-1655.
Hausler, R H 2013, 'Formulating Test Environments for Evaluating Corrosion and Sour Cracking Resistance of Carbon Steel and Low Alloys: The Equation of State for Closed Systems Revisited,' in NACE CORROSION 2013, pp. NACE-2013.
Hausler, R H, Krishnamurthy, R, Gomez, J & Kusinski, G 2017, 'Methodology for Materials Selection Basis of Design, and Equipment Testing Criteria,' in Offshore Technology Conference, p. D021S024R004.
Krishnamurthy, R M, Hausler, R H & Tandon, S 2019, 'Implications of Using the Fugacity (Activity in the Gas Phase) of the Acid Gases in the Design of Qualification Testing of Oilfield Tubular Materials,' in NACE CORROSION 2019, pp. NACE-2019.
Lichti, K., Julian, R., Brown, K., Villafuerte, G., & Dambe, R. (2021). Scaling and Corrosion Control in a High Chloride Geothermal Brine. Proceedings World Geothermal Congress, October, 2–7.
Morana, R, Venkateswaran, S P, Smith, L, Trillo, E & Intiso, L 2021, ‘Case Study on the Downhole Materials Selection and Sour Service Qualification for a High Pressure, High Temperature Gas Field,’ in NACE CORROSION 2021, pp. NACE-2021.
Richardson, I, Addison, S & Thompson, G 2013, ‘Steam purity considerations in geothermal power generation’, Proceedings of the New Zealand Geothermal Workshop, (November), p. 8.
Salonga, N D & Lichti, K A 2005, ‘Application of risk based inspection methodology to aging geothermal fluid collection and disposal system in Tongonan , Philippines’, World Geothermal Congress, (April), pp. 24–29.
Sun, W & Srdjan, N 2007, ‘A Mechanistic Model of H2S Corrosion of Mild Steel’, NACE corrosion.
Thorbjornsson, I O, Bjornsson, S, Sigurdsson, O & Palsson, H 2020, 'Materials investigation of the high-temperature IDDP-1 wellhead', Geothermics.
Troiano, A. R., & Hehemann, R. F. (1978). Hydrogen sulfide stress corrosion cracking in materials for geothermal power.
Villa, R R & Salonga, N D 2000, ‘Corrosion Induced By Steam Condensates in Upper Mahiao Pipeline , Leyte , Philippines’, Proceedings World Geothermal Congress 2000, (May 1998), pp. 3335–3340.
Recommended Citation
Pragitta, Riene Kaelamanda and Pratesa, Yudha
(2025)
"Assessment of H2S-Induced Cracking Susceptibility in Steam Line Pipes and Weld Zones During Geothermal Well Construction,"
Journal of Materials Exploration and Findings: Vol. 4:
Iss.
1, Article 5.
DOI: 10.7454/jmef.v4i1.1089
Available at:
https://scholarhub.ui.ac.id/jmef/vol4/iss1/5
Included in
Chemical Engineering Commons, Chemicals and Drugs Commons, Computational Engineering Commons, Condensed Matter Physics Commons, Fluid Dynamics Commons, Materials Chemistry Commons, Mechanical Engineering Commons, Metallurgy Commons, Mining Engineering Commons, Natural Products Chemistry and Pharmacognosy Commons, Operations Research, Systems Engineering and Industrial Engineering Commons, Other Engineering Commons, Polymer Chemistry Commons, Risk Analysis Commons, Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics Commons
