Antropologi Indonesia
Abstract
This article studies the dynamics of customary land ownership in Papua New Guinea (PNG), where approximately 97 percent of land is collectively held by clans. Drawing on insights from political anthropology—particularly normative pluralism (Griffiths, 1986; von Benda-Beckmann, 2006), Polanyi's double movement (Filer, 2014), along with cosmological perspectives on land and identity (Weiner & Glaskin, 2007; Ingold, 2021), it analyzes how government efforts to formalize customary land through the Land Act 1996 and the Incorporated Land Groups (ILG) Act 2009 generate three principal paradoxes: (1) protection versus exclusion, (2) recognition versus commodification, and (3) negotiation versus rigidity. The study blends an overview of existing literature with limited ethnographic fieldwork conducted in the Eastern Highlands, Simbu, and Jiwaka Provinces of PNG. A comparison with Indonesia, focusing on customary land conflicts in Indonesian Papua traced chronologically through the Freeport concession in Timika (Central Papua Province), the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate (MIFEE, now part of the National Strategic Projects food estate program), and forest encroachment in Boven Digoel (both in South Papua Province), reveals two contrasting models: PNG's adat-centric system, which is susceptible to commodification, and Indonesia's state-centric system, which struggles to protect customary rights. The Papua cases show three successive forms of state-mediated legibility—early legal invisibility under Freeport, subordinated visibility under MIFEE, and administratively visible but conditional recognition in Boven Digoel—demonstrating that visibility, legal recognition, protection, and political agency are analytically distinct and do not follow automatically from one another. The article contends that legal recognition alone is inadequate; effective protection of customary land requires an understanding of indigenous cosmology to reinforce collective sovereignty and prevent new forms of exclusion. It draws a critical lesson from PNG: clan-based landholding offers a model for recognizing indigenous communities as holders of authority over customary territory rather than as beneficiaries of state procedure, yet the elite capture, exclusion, and commodification associated with ILGs mean that Indonesia should adapt, not replicate, this model. It further argues that the formalization of customary land tenure not only affects indigenous land rights but also produces structural paradoxes that alter authority, representation, and territorial visibility. The article's contribution depends on demonstrating that these paradoxes of formalization reflect a recurring structural tension between state transparency as well as indigenous relational land systems, a tension that cannot be resolved through law reforms alone.
Bahasa Abstract
Artikel ini mengkaji dinamika kepemilikan tanah adat di Papua Nugini (PNG), dimana sekitar 97 persen tanah dimiliki secara kolektif oleh marga. Berdasarkan wawasan dari antropologi politik—khususnya pluralisme normatif (Griffiths, 1986; von Benda-Beckmann, 2006), gerakan ganda Polanyi (Filer, 2014), serta perspektif kosmologis mengenai tanah dan identitas (Weiner & Glaskin, 2007; Ingold, 2021), penelitian ini menganalisis bagaimana upaya pemerintah untuk meresmikan tanah adat melalui Undang-undang Pertanahan tahun 1996 dan Undang-Undang Pertanahan yang Digabungkan. Undang-Undang Kelompok (ILG) tahun 2009 menghasilkan tiga paradoks utama: (1) perlindungan versus eksklusi, (2) pengakuan versus komodifikasi, dan (3) negosiasi versus kekakuan. Studi ini memadukan tinjauan literatur yang ada dengan penelitian lapangan etnografi terbatas yang dilakukan di Provinsi Dataran Tinggi Timur, Simbu, dan Jiwaka, PNG. Jika dibandingkan dengan Indonesia, dengan fokus pada konflik tanah adat di Papua yang ditelusuri secara kronologis melalui konsesi Freeport di Timika (Provinsi Papua Tengah), Perkebunan Pangan dan Energi Terpadu Merauke (MIFEE, sekarang bagian dari program food estate Proyek Strategis Nasional), dan perambahan hutan di Boven Digoel (keduanya di Provinsi Papua Selatan), mengungkapkan dua model yang kontras: sistem adat-sentris di PNG, yang rentan terhadap komodifikasi, dan sistem negara-sentris di Indonesia, yang berjuang untuk melindungi adat hak. Kasus-kasus di Papua menunjukkan tiga bentuk keterbacaan yang dimediasi oleh negara—ketidaktampakan hukum awal di bawah Freeport, keterlihatan yang tersubordinasi di bawah MIFEE, dan keterbacaan yang terlihat secara administratif namun bersyarat di Boven Digoel—menunjukkan bahwa keterlihatan, pengakuan hukum, perlindungan, dan lembaga politik secara analitis berbeda dan tidak terjadi secara otomatis satu sama lain. Artikel tersebut berpendapat bahwa pengakuan hukum saja tidaklah cukup; perlindungan yang efektif atas tanah adat memerlukan pemahaman tentang kosmologi adat untuk memperkuat kedaulatan kolektif dan mencegah bentuk-bentuk pengucilan baru. Hal ini menarik pelajaran penting dari PNG: kepemilikan tanah berbasis klan menawarkan sebuah model untuk mengakui masyarakat adat sebagai pemegang otoritas atas wilayah adat dan bukan sebagai penerima manfaat dari prosedur negara, namun penguasaan elit, eksklusi, dan komodifikasi yang terkait dengan ILG berarti bahwa Indonesia harus mengadaptasi, bukan meniru, model ini. Laporan ini lebih lanjut menyatakan bahwa formalisasi kepemilikan tanah adat tidak hanya berdampak pada hak adat atas tanah tetapi juga menghasilkan paradoks struktural yang mengubah kewenangan, keterwakilan, dan visibilitas teritorial. Kontribusi artikel ini bergantung pada demonstrasi bahwa paradoks formalisasi ini mencerminkan ketegangan struktural yang berulang antara transparansi negara dan sistem pertanahan adat, sebuah ketegangan yang tidak dapat diselesaikan melalui reformasi hukum saja.
References
Allen, M. G. (2016) Islands, extraction and violence: Mining and the politics of scale in Island Melanesia. Political Geography, 57, 81–90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2016.12.004
Ambelye, I. (2019) Youth’s displaced aggression in rural Papua New Guinea. In H. Lee (Ed.), Pacific youth: Local and global futures (pp. 183–201). Canberra: ANU Press. https://doi.org/10.22459/PY.2019.08
Arizona, Y., & Cahyadi, E. I. (2019) Hukum agraria adat dan hak ulayat: Dinamika pengakuan dan perlindungan. Epistema Institute.
Bainton, N., Alexeyeff, K., McDougall, D., & Cox, J. (Eds.) (2020) Unequal lives: Gender, race and class in the Western Pacific. ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/UE.2020
Bainton, N., & Skrzypek, E. E. (Eds.) (2021) The absent presence of the state in large-scale resource extraction projects. ANU Press. https://doi.org/10.22459/AP.2021
Ballard, C. (2002) Human Rights and the Mining Industry in Indonesia: a baseline study. Canberra: Australian National University.
Banks, G. (2008) Understanding ‘resource’ conflicts in Papua New Guinea. Asia Pacific Viewpoint, 49(1), 23–34. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8373.2008.00358.x
Banović, B. (2016) The Montenegrin Warrior Tradition. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137552280
Barclay, K., & Cartwright, I. (2008) Capturing wealth from tuna: Case studies from the Pacific. ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/CWT.01.2008
Basuki, I., Adinugroho, W. C., Utomo, N. A., Syaugi, A., Tryanto, D. H., Krisnawati, H., Cook-Patton, S. C., & Novita, N. (2022) Reforestation Opportunities in Indonesia: Mitigating Climate Change and Achieving Sustainable Development Goals. Forests, 13(3), 447. https://doi.org/10.3390/f13030447
Bedner, A., & van Huis, S. C. (2008) The return of the native in Indonesian law: Indigenous communities in Indonesian legislation. Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde, 164(2–3), 165–193.
Bizhan, N., & Gorea, E. G. (2022) A weak state and strong microsocieties in Papua New Guinea. In N. Bizhan (Ed.), State fragility around the world (pp. 221–246). Routledge.
Bourke, R. M. (2009) History of agriculture in Papua New Guinea. In R. M. Bourke & T. Harwood (Eds.), Food and agriculture in Papua New Guinea (pp. 10–26). ANU Press.
Colchester, M., Jiwan, N., Andiko, Sirait, M., Firdaus, A. Y., Surambo, A., & Pane, H. (2006) Promised land: Palm oil and land acquisition in Indonesia—Implications for local communities and indigenous peoples. Forest Peoples Programme.
Denham, T., Golson, J., & Hughes, P. J. (Eds.) (2017) Ten thousand years of cultivation at Kuk Swamp in the highlands of Papua New Guinea. ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/TA46.07.2017
ERIAS Group (2020) Indigenous peoples plan Papua New Guinea. Port Moresby: ERIAS Group.
Farran, S. (2017) Kastom, Property and Ideology: Land Transformations in Melanesia. The Journal of Pacific History, 52(3), 425–426. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223344.2017.1382431
Filer, C. (2006) Custom, law and ideology in Papua New Guinea. The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology, 7(1), 65–84. https://doi.org/10.1080/14442210600554499
Filer, C. (2014) The Double Movement of Immovable Property Rights in Papua New Guinea. The Journal of Pacific History, 49(1), 76–94. http://www.jstor.org/stable/24644471
Filer, C. (2017) The formation of a land grab policy network in Papua New Guinea. In S. McDonnell, M. Allen, & C. Filer (Eds.), Kastom, property and ideology: Land transformations in Melanesia. Canberra: ANU Press. https://doi.org/10.22459/KPI.03.2017.06
Filer, C., & Le Meur, P.-Y. (2017) Large-scale mines and local-level politics: Between New Caledonia and Papua New Guinea. Canberra: ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/LMLP.10.2017
Fingleton, J. (2007) A legal regime for issuing group titles to customary land: Lessons from the East Sepik. In J. F. Weiner & K. Glaskin (Eds.), Customary land tenure and registration in Australia and Papua New Guinea (pp. 15–38). ANU Press.
Firth, S., & Naidu, V. (Eds.) (2019) Understanding Oceania: Celebrating the University of the South Pacific and its collaboration with The Australian National University. ANU Press. http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctvk8vzcb
Fitzpatrick, P. (1980) Law and state in Papua New Guinea. London: Academic Press.
Golub, A. (2007) From agency to agents: Forging landowner identities in Porgera. In J. F. Weiner & K. Glaskin (Eds.), Customary land tenure and registration in Australia and Papua New Guinea (pp. 73–96). Canberra: ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/CLTRAPNG.06.2007
Griffiths, J. (1986) What is Legal Pluralism? The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 18(24), 1–55. https://doi.org/10.1080/07329113.1986.10756387
Haley, N., & May, R. J. (2007) Conflict and resource development in the Southern Highlands of Papua New Guinea. Canberra: ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/CRD.11.2007
Hambloch, C. (2021) Land formalization turned land rush: The case of oil palm in Papua New Guinea. Land Use Policy, 112, 105818. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105818
Henley, D., & Davidson, J. S. (2008) In the Name of Adat: Regional Perspectives on Reform, Tradition, and Democracy in Indonesia. Modern Asian Studies, 42(4), 815–852. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0026749X07003083
Hodgson, D. L., & Schroeder, R. A. (2002) Dilemmas of counter-mapping community resources in Tanzania. Development and Change, 33(1), 79–100. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-7660.00241
Imen, I. P., & Jacob, A. (2021) Sustainability assessment of land transactions and project benefits sharing in Papua New Guinea. Journal of Land Management and Appraisal, 8(1), 13–27. https://doi.org/10.5897/JLMA2021.0022
Ingold, T. (2021) The Perception of the Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003196662
Jørgensen, D. (2007) Clan-finding, clan-making and the politics of identity in a Papua New Guinea mining project. In J. F. Weiner & K. Glaskin (Eds.), Customary land tenure and registration in Australia and Papua New Guinea (pp. 57–72). Canberra: ANU Press.
Karigawa, L. (2018) Eroding Fabrics of Communal Land Ownership in Papua New Guinea. International Journal of Environment, Agriculture and Biotechnology, 3(4), 1353–1364. https://doi.org/10.22161/ijeab/3.4.29
Kirsch, S. (2014) Mining capitalism: The relationship between corporations and their critics. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kurniawan, K. F. B., Dharmawan, A. H., Sumarti, T., & Maksum, M. (2024) Territorialization of plantation concessions: customary land acquisition process, agrarian fragmentation and social resistance. Cogent Social Sciences, 10(1). https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2024.2367259
Lea, D. (2002) Incorporated land groups: Part of the problem or part of the solution? Pacific Economic Bulletin, 17(1), 79–90.
Leith, D. (2003) The politics of power: Freeport in Suharto’s Indonesia. Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press.
Li, T. M. (2014) Land's End: Capitalist Relations on an Indigenous Frontier. Durham: Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1215/9780822376460
Lindsey, T., & Butt, S. (2018) Indonesian Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
May, R. (2012) Papua New Guinea: Issues of External and Internal Security. Security Challenges, 8(4), 47–60. http://www.jstor.org/stable/26462890
Mayastuti, A., Rianto, A., & Atika Sari, D. A. (2017) Strengthening the position of indigenous people in the management of the forest by subsequent of the Constitutional Court decision of Republic Indonesia No. 35/PUU-X/2012 to support REDD+ Indonesia. Yustisia Jurnal Hukum, 6(2), 400–412. https://jurnal.uns.ac.id/yustisia/article/view/12866/11008
McDonnell, J. E. (2021) The Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate (MIFEE): An Ecologically Induced Genocide of the Malind Anim. Journal of Genocide Research, 23(2), 257–278. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623528.2020.1799593
Minnegal, M., & Dwyer, P. D. (2017) Navigating the future: An ethnography of desire in highland Papua New Guinea. Canberra: ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/NTF.06.2017
Moniaga, S. (2007) From bumiputera to masyarakat adat: A long and confusing journey. In J. S. Davidson & D. Henley (Eds.), The revival of tradition in Indonesian politics: The deployment of adat from colonialism to indigenism (pp. 275–294). London: Routledge.
Myers, R., Intarini, D., Sirait, M., & Maryudi, A. (2017) Claiming the forest: Inclusions and exclusions under Indonesia’s “new” forest policies on customary forests. Land Use Policy, 66, 205–213. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2017.04.039
Patterson, M., & Macintyre, M. (Eds.) (2011) Managing modernity in the Western Pacific: Globalisation, identity and social change. Brisbane: University of Queensland Press.
Peluso, N. L. (1995) Whose woods are these? Counter-mapping forest territories in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Antipode, 27(4), 383–406. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8330.1995.tb00286.x
Prideaux, M. (2006) Leadership in Papua New Guinea: exploring context and barriers. In: Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management. From: 2006 Annual Conference of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management, 6–10 December 2006, Rockhampton, QLD, Australia.
Reumi, F., & Katjong, K. (2021) The legal standing of ulayat rights and communal land rights based on knowledge and kinship systems in Sentani customary law, Jayapura Regency, Papua. International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding, 8(9), 244–255. http://dx.doi.org/10.18415/ijmmu.v8i9.2982
Rooney, M. N. (2021) “We Want Development”: Land and Water (Dis)connections in Port Moresby, Urban Papua New Guinea. The Contemporary Pacific, 33(1), 1–30. https://www.jstor.org/stable/27126719
Roth, R. (2009) The challenges of mapping complex indigenous spatiality: From abstract space to dwelling space. Cultural Geographies, 16(2), 207–227. https://doi.org/10.1177/1474474008101517
Safitri, M. (2017) Hukum Adat di Indonesia: Politik Pengakuan, Transformasi, dan Kontestasi. Jakarta: HuMa.
Salima, F. A. (2024, March 27) Profil 6 provinsi di Papua, ada yang tidak punya laut. Detik.com. https://www.detik.com/sulsel/berita/d-7262042/profil-6-provinsi-di-papua-ada-yang-tidak-punya-laut
Schwoerer, T. (2024) Large-Scale Land Transformations and Changing Sociality among the Wampar in Papua New Guinea. Anthropological Forum, 34(2), 209–225. https://doi.org/10.1080/00664677.2023.2247174
Scott, J. C. (1998) Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Simarmata, R. (2024) The current updates of the progress and challenges of customary forest recognition in Indonesia. Jurnal Ilmu Kehutanan, 18(2), 142–156. https://doi.org/10.22146/jik.v18i2.12660
Suartina, T. (2020) Between control and empowerment: Local government and acknowledgement of adat villages in Indonesia. Indonesia Law Review, 10(3), 363–382. https://doi.org/10.15742/ilrev.v10n3.679
Swardhana, G. M., & Jenvitchuwong, S. (2023) The political structure of Indonesia's regulation to protect customary forests. Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 3(2), 308–322. https://doi.org/10.53955/jhcls.v3i1.72
Trebilcock, M. J. (1983) Customary land law reform in Papua New Guinea: Law, economics and property rights in a traditional culture. Adelaide Law Review, 9, 191–214.
von Benda-Beckmann, F. (2006) The Multiple Edges of Law: Dealing with Legal Pluralism in Development Practice. In The World Bank Legal Review, Volume 2: Law, Equity, and Development (pp. 51–86). Washington, DC: World Bank.
Weiner, J. F., & Glaskin, K. (Eds.) (2007) Customary Land Tenure and Registration in Australia and Papua New Guinea: Anthropological Perspectives. Canberra: ANU Press. http://doi.org/10.22459/CLTRAPNG.06.2007
Zimmer-Tamakoshi, L., & Brewer, C. (2012) Troubled Masculinities and Gender Violence in Melanesia. In M. Jolly & C. Stewart (Eds.), Engendering Violence in Papua New Guinea (pp. 73–106). ANU Press. http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt24hcwt.9
Recommended Citation
Prasetijo, Adi
(2026)
"Paradoxes of Customary Land Formalization: A Comparative Study of Papua New Guinea And Indonesia From a Political Anthropology Perspective,"
Antropologi Indonesia: Vol. 47:
Iss.
2, Article 2.
DOI: 10.7454/jai.v46i2.1256
Available at:
https://scholarhub.ui.ac.id/jai/vol47/iss2/2