Developing an on-campus creative economy clinic to elevate the quality of existing community service program

The ongoing community service program has not provided optimal and sustainable outcomes that can improve the creative economy sector as a partner, especially in the era of technological disruption. This study describes the importance of setting up a creative economy clinic at the university, which is based on the needs of upscaling local micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs’) performance. The discussions presented in the paper arise from a qualitative conceptual study using an instrumental case study approach, linking insights from theoretical perspectives and works across disciplines that concern the development of a creative economy clinic. The results of the discussion highlight the potential outcomes of establishing an on-campus creative economy clinic, ensuring the business sustainability of MSMEs in the era of disruptive technology. An initial assessment related to the needs of MSMEs is required as a strategic step in the development of the ecosystem of related creative economy clinics using each university’s competitive advantage.


Introduction
The Fourth Industrial Revolution has led to the rapid development of technologies and computer-based applications and provided new challenges to developed and developing countries, including Indonesia. Many things related to human lifestyles are controlled by the latest technology, highlighting another significant element of the disruption era. To overcome these challenges, Indonesia should strengthen its potential, especially in the creative economy. As stated by the UNDP (2013), the creative economy is currently not considered a dynamic economic sector. Generally, the creative economy sector provides economic benefits for developing countries to grow and emerge with an inclusive and sustainable level of economic growth (Badan Ekonomi Kreatif, 2017).
The creative economy and related industries have become a dynamic economic driver in the modern world. Despite the different contextual issues within the creative economy universities in Malaysia have formed an entrepreneurial agenda. Recently, Bomani, Fields, and Derera (2019) and Hunjet Kozina, and Kurečić (2015) examined the role of higher education institutions in the development of SMEs in Zimbabwe. Generally, the results of the studies indicate that tertiary institutions play a significant role in developing SMEs through training, technology transfer, business incubators, research, and research commercialization.
In the Indonesian context, to the best of the author's knowledge, there is only one study that is relevant to the role of Indonesian higher education institutions in the development of MSMEs in Indonesia. The review conducted by Dessy (2007) underlines the contribution of several large universities in Indonesia, such as Gadjah Mada University (UGM) and Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB) of the transfer of knowledge and technology to local SMEs. The knowledge and technology transfer mechanisms are manifested through business incubation programs that are managed explicitly by each university. But generally, in her conceptual study, Dessy (2007) highlighted the ineffective role of higher education institutions by both lecturers as individuals and universities as institutions in managing the sustainable development and empowerment program. Thus, the synergy between universities, industry, and government to advance SMEs in the context of the triple helix remains a mere slogan.
The Ministry of Education and Culture through the Directorate General of Research and Development has long provided a stimulus for community service programs to lecturers in Indonesia. However, its effectiveness is still questionable and is marked by the stagnant performance of MSMEs post the start of the community service program.
Also, MSMEs in Indonesia still face obstacles in running and developing their businesses.
They face increasingly complex problems, especially in the era of global markets. In many cases, multiple issues MSMEs face, such as access to finance, organization and human resources, business opportunities, bureaucracy and regulation, and bookkeeping can be easily managed. However, the resolution of these issues tends to be unsatisfactory as they are rarely complete and sustainable, particularly within MSME. | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 One of the government's initiatives is to improve infrastructure to facilitate the in-andoutflows of goods produced by MSMEs. The existence of good infrastructure should also be supported by updating the MSMEs' capacity, especially in terms of using digital technology. By the end of 2018, only 5 percent of MSMEs in Indonesia were digital, and many more can still go digital. The lack of community interest in using existing digitalized media and the tendency of people accessing information from cellphones instead of computers have contributed to the ineffective performance of MSMEs in the adoption of technology in their business operations (Widiastuti & Tjokropandojo, 2016).
Accordingly, universities in Indonesia should continue in their efforts to design various strategic work programs. These attempts are encouraged to support the growth and development of MSMEs, which are projected in the development and establishment of the creative economy clinical models. The existence of the creative economy clinic is sought to overcome the challenges and demands of conditions in the era of technological disruption and in welcoming the age of Society 5.0. At present, the trend toward the use of technology has narrowed to a human-centric paradigm (Fukuyama, 2018). Thus, a proper understanding and usage of digital technology by MSME actors will impact on strengthening the value chain of their businesses through innovation both in the virtual world and in reality, and fulfill the needs of the super-smart society segment.
To the best of the authors' knowledge, neither a conceptual paper nor a related empirical study has been found that investigates the importance of establishing a creative economy clinic in the university context. The lack of academic references provided in this area also justifies the ineffectiveness of current community research and service initiatives put forward by the university staff. The inefficiency arises from the nonholistic and temporary implications of research and service conducted in communities, which tend to be ceremonial. Activities and outcomes resulting in research and community service are probably undertaken as a regular academic procedure by lecturers and researchers at the universities. However, the Indonesian government has raised concerns about universities using research and community service outputs that will benefit stakeholders, including MSMEs.
Industry and the creative economy are the primary focus of business and government actors, given the enormous potential of these sectors, especially for MSMEs. In the national economy, MSMEs have an essential and strategic role. It is evident from the | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 various empirical data that MSMEs are quite dominant in the Indonesian economy (Munandar, 2016). The success of the creative economy sector is inseparable from the role of government, entrepreneurs, academics, and the community that are bound together in the quadruple helix model introduced by Etzkowitz (2008). Besides, as a strategic facilitator for stakeholders in the development of the creative economy, lecturers and universities play an essential role in training, transfer of knowledge, and technology to MSMEs (Efi, 2014). Furthermore, the knowledge gained through training builds MSME technology capabilities, which can improve product quality and MSME services (Chipangura & Kaseke, 2012).

The role of University and Lecturers in the development of the creative economy
The theory on the importance of organizational partnerships was put forward by Eisler and Montuori (2001) in 1998. An organizational partnership is needed as a strategy for organizational development faced with global uncertainty. Accordingly, an organization should collaborate closely with other organizations so that it can produce products at maximum quality and quantity (Herawati, 2011).
As explained in the introduction section, involving other stakeholders in a partnership setting is pivotal for (MSMEs) to cope with the dynamic of the existing MSME business environment. Related to this understanding, the government has positioned universities to play a central role in economic development (O'Malley, 2016). That universities have become engines for national prosperity is supported by Alexander and Evgeniy (2012), who state that "universities are agents of economic and technological development." Therefore, universities are increasingly expected to build and maintain relationships with the business sector, especially SMEs (Piterou & Birch, 2014). They (SMEs) constitute more than 95 percent of the total registered businesses in the world and contribute to approximately 60 percent of jobs in the private sector and more than 50 percent of the world's GDP (D'Imperio, 2013).
A study by Efi (2014) reveals that universities in Nigeria play an essential role in training, transfer of knowledge, and technology to local SMEs. The knowledge gained through training in building the technological capabilities of SMEs has consequently improved the quality of products and services (Chipangura & Kaseke, 2012). More importantly, universities make their research findings available on the Internet following | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 the increasing number of online academic journals published by academics and researchers (Bacigalupo, Kampylis, Punie, & Van den Brande, 2016;Bergmann, Geissler, Hundt, & Grave, 2018;Boldureanu et al., 2020;Ismulyati and Ginting, 2018;Mei & Symaco, 2020). Furthermore, the research findings provide essential sources and valuable information for SMEs to grow and develop their businesses (Bomani, Fields, & Derera, 2019;Delfmann & Koster, 2012). The partnership between universities and MSMEs through direct and sustainable assistance has a positive impact on the development of the creative economy sector. This study's findings agrees with Plechero Not much different from the practice in several countries outlined in the previous paragraph, universities in Indonesia have still focused on the educational aspects, including consulting for structural and managerial improvements of business operations | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 of creative economy sector actors (Doyle, 2016;Fahmi, McCann & Koster, 2015;Gasparin & Quinn, 2020;Kaymas, 2020;Kontrimienė & Melnikas, 2017;Moore, 2014).
Additionally, Fahmi, McCann and Koster (2015) also underline the accommodation of subjects relevant to the creative economy in entrepreneurship study programs at several universities in Bandung, Yogyakarta, and Surakarta as the object of their case studies.

The influence of the existence of a business incubator in The University on the development of creative economy
A business incubator is an institution that helps new entrepreneurs start their businesses to improve their prospects for development and endurance so that they can survive in a real business environment. According to Agustina (2011), a business incubator is a vehicle for transforming human resources that are not or are less creative and productive into those who are entrepreneurially motivated, creative, innovative, productive and cooperative, and who have competitive advantages, as well as vision and mission.
The concept of a business incubator in tertiary institutions has excellent potential to create new entrepreneurs through a business incubator program. The attempt is relevant to two significant tasks attached to the lecturers. They are to conduct research and community service activities consistent with their field of expertize. The actions of research and community service are expected to transform academic research findings into innovation so that a process of value creation can occur in societies. The outcomes are also likely to assist MSMEs in applying relevant technology to create and improve people's welfare (Campbell, 1989;Famiola & Hartati, 2018;Li et al., 2020;Ndabeni, 2008;Obaji et al., 2015;Ogutu & Kihonge, 2016;Pettersen, Aarstad, Høvig, & Tobiassen 2015;Salem, 2014).
The existence of a business incubator in the higher education institution is instrumental in expanding existing businesses in the community and universities. The on-campus business incubator can further result in a university's profit center arising from the university's facilities and business units managed by the business incubator (Suwandi, 2007). However, these expectations seem not to perform correctly. The existence of business incubators in tertiary institutions does still not optimally accelerate the development of the creative economy. The reason is that the ecosystem supporting Andri Zainal, T. Citra Nissa Farza, Khairunnisa Harahap, Pasca Dwi Putra | ASEAN Journal of Community Engagement | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 the role of the incubator has weaknesses in the incubator's governance system, such as (1) managers not being able to work full time; (2) the status of the business incubator autonomy and the time constraints of the incubator manager who is also a lecturer or researcher at the tertiary institution concerned; (3) coaching is conducted externally; (4) the administration includes but is not limited to an accompanying agreement or contract; and (5) operational funds are still minimal because they only rely on funding from tertiary institutions.
Accordingly, business incubators are only slightly incorporated into business incubator associations, and many business incubator managers do not have access to training or education on managing business incubators. The ratio of assistants and tenants is not proportional enough, and there is an insufficient frequency of intensive assistance and optimal quality of support. Weaknesses in management aspects and business incubator facilities are closely related to the structure of university business incubator financing (Agustina, 2011;Hasbullah et al., 2015;Suwandi, 2007).
The non-optimal role of managers in conducting their main tasks and functions within the incubator and the weak governance system results in the objectives of the business incubator not being achieved. The poor performance of the business incubator indicates that the incubator is treated as a supplementary formality in the accreditation instrument. It adds an extra burden on universities fulfilling the Tri Dharma role of tertiary institutions, which focuses on education, research, and community service within the framework of scientific development (Suwandi, 2007).
Further, the lack of an optimal business incubator in tertiary institutions is caused by the lack of a variety of products or business units within the business incubator. So, it is less able to meet market needs in the local, national, and international scope. Agustina This study conceptually explores the need for establishing a creative economy clinic in tertiary institutions. More specifically, this discussion paper is generated from qualitative research toward actualizing an attempt to develop a creative economic clinic model at universities in Indonesia. The establishment of the creative economy model is expected to increase outcomes gained from the community service program and existing business incubators, sustainably. The next section discusses the qualitative research method, followed by a contextual exploration related to the initial mapping needed for the development of a creative economy clinic on campus. The author includes a qualitative study that specifically highlights the urgency of the existence of a creative economy clinic based on reviews related to the ineffectiveness of the role of business incubators in creating new startups. The last section contains the conclusions and implications of establishing a creative economy clinic for upgrading the community service program by increasing the mutual capacity and intensity of lecturers and MSMEs as partners in the creative economy clinic on campus.

Methods
The paper discusses the importance of establishing the creative economy model at a university from the authors' viewpoint. The basic idea of this paper stems from the phenomenon of the weak outcomes of existing community service programs conducted by lecturers as community service professionals that have real and sustainable impacts on MSMEs as implementing partners. It is also inspired by the modern medical treatment model operated in public health centers or clinics and specialty medical clinics, justifying the theoretical foundation for modeling the creative economy clinic on campus. The arguments are formed by the observation that focuses on a meaning-making as a qualitative scientific method (Krauss, 2005). This study emphasizes the attempt at developing logical and complete arguments, bridging Eisler and Montuori's (2001) theory of partnership of organizations and working across disciplines to expand the scope of thinking (Gilson & Goldberg, 2015). Here, based on Gilson and Goldberg (2015), the link synthesizes multi-level insights that further underline the potential outcomes of the application of a creative economy clinical model in a university setting.
The approach of designing this conceptual paper pinpoints the theory synthesis type of paper proposed by Jaakkola (2020), highlighting a specific domain of discussion as the starting point, which, in this case, is the importance of establishing an on-campus creative economy clinic. This fundamental concept is further regarded as a variable equivalent being studied in the empirical research design. More specifically, to construct the discourse following steps developed by McGregor (2018). This research started from (a) | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 investigating a specific issue, (b) compiling, generating, and evaluating relevant evidence, (c) establishing the importance of the focal topic that further creates a novelty of the paper, and (d) organizing sound, logic, and reasoning argumentation of the issue.
The analytical procedures used in this literature review are in-line with the instrumental case study approach (Stake, 1995). The intended case study includes a review of the syntheses published in books, journals, and mass media that are relevant to the specific issue emphasized in this paper, namely, the development of a creative economy clinic on campus. Stake (1995) further highlights the outcome of the exploration of various materials that are relevant to issues related to improving an existing condition.
The state is to improve the quality of community service programs in the creative economy sector conducted by university lecturers. In particular, the requirement of setting up a creative economy clinic originates from the ongoing community research and service practices involving researchers from universities in Indonesia and local MSMEs as the partner.

Qualitative analysis of the development of the creative economy clinic model:
Incorporating the quadruple helix approach The quadruple helix concept builds on the triple helix concept by integrating the roles of academics, entrepreneurs, government, and society into creative activities and knowledge. Good collaboration among the four quadruple helix actors is needed so that each can play their role in encouraging the growth of the creative industry. Academics and companies provide the conditions required for an integrated innovation ecosystem.
The government provides a regulatory framework and financial support for the definition and implementation of innovative strategies and policies. Civil society not only uses and applies knowledge, and demands innovation in the form of goods and services, but also becomes an active part as a user and operator in the innovation system. The additional helix includes civil society, comprising a media and culture-based society (Praswati, 2017).
Discussions on creativity and innovation performance in the creative industry with the support of quadruple helix are still unclear and still very limited. Currently, the Indonesian government is working to improve the quality of human resources in the creative industry to be more innovative, creative, and proactive so that they can engage in an innovation-based economy. As this research focuses on the scope of tertiary institutions, it is crucial to redefine the quadruple helix model in terms of developing the creative economy sector through the role of lecturers and tertiary institutions as researchers and community service.
Generally, academics, as researchers and community service professionals, have a role in providing new knowledge generated from research and development activities. Apart from acting as researchers and community facilitators, lecturers and tertiary institutions also act as a medium connecting the synergy among MSMEs, the community, government, companies, and financial institutions. The objective is to create an ideal business ecosystem that supports the conditions required for the Fourth Industrial Revolution and Society 5.0 eras. As a facilitator that synergies other stakeholders, lecturers and universities must have digital-based competencies as essential skills. They | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 are also required to have the competence to build networks to expand the knowledge and research directions that anticipate future constraints. More importantly, they must maintain cooperation among MSMEs, communities, governments, companies, and financial institutions to optimize the role in practice.

The need for developing the on-campus creative economy clinic
The increase in public awareness of the importance of high-quality services influences the increased demand for every public or private institution to provide optimal services in all aspects of life. In coping with the issue, universities in Indonesia intend to initiate a more effective community service strategy by setting up a creative economic clinic model to transfer skills to and empower MSMEs.
In the initial stages of developing the model, it was necessary to conduct a preliminary study identifying the needs of MSMEs in managing a sustainable business. Gronroos (1990) developed the Know Your Customers (KYC) strategy, which is considered one of the most meaningful service strategies, is used to provide excellent service by recognizing the needs and desires of users of the service. The KYC strategy in public services is used to verify the needs, interests, and aspirations of service users so that service delivery is responded to promptly. The KYC strategy provides excellent quality public services; hence, people are satisfied with the services offered (Rofida, 2018). This article identified the respondent's background information, which resulted in the profiles of both the MSME owner and the MSME. Indicators in the profile of MSME owners consist of general identity (full name, gender, age, last education, and address). The relevant descriptive statistic shows a dominant proportion of relatively young and productive micro-and small-sector-entrepreneurs in Medan City (25-29 years of age), | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 75.5 percent from 207 local MSMEs followed by 17.8 percent and 6.7 percent of entrepreneurs aged 15-24 years old and over 60-years-old, respectively.

The profile of the business owner is important because some of the results of studies
show that the poor quality of human resources can be seen by the low level of education of MSME owners. The frequency of MSME managers who have at least a diploma degree and above is considered minor (6.7 percent). In contrast, most MSME managers with senior high school leaving certificates or equivalent, and those with lower degrees amounted to 57.2 and 36.1 percent, respectively. The low level of education leads to MSME entrepreneurs being unable to grow their businesses and increase productivity (Nainggolan, 2016).
Gender is also predicted as one of the determining factors for the success of the business. The descriptive statistics concerning this indicator show that 24.15 percent of women are both the owner and manager of MSMEs, indicating that fewer women own and manage MSMEs than men (Kim & Sherraden, 2014).
The use of other MSME profile indicators comprises (1) the current status of the business scope, (2) the type of MSME, (3) the tenure of the business, (4) the location of business operations, (5) business size in terms of revenue, and (6) the percentage of operating costs from income earned. These indicators can be a fruitful area for future studies. Some information related to these business profiles provides essential information on the ratio of business success to the scope of a business undertaken.
We opted to update the survey instrument for subsequent research by incorporating some indicators developed by the United Kingdom's Department of Business Innovations and Skill. The respective indicators explore business performance, problem needs, and factors that inhibit growth, to identify the needs of MSME owners for their business in the short and long term (Darwish, 2014). They are ( The results of the identification of MSME performance, especially those of the MSME needs, the description of business support and business consultations obtained, and the mechanism favored by MSME actors will assist the university in developing an efficient and effective creative economic clinic model that meets the needs of MSMEs.
The development of clinical models will provide recommendations on types of services that suit the needs of MSMEs. They will offer more individual services based on each business sector with different business settings such as culinary, computer and information technology, construction, education, entertainment, financial services, retailers, health care, and others. These types of services are supported by consultants with specific skill sets and competent stakeholders to strengthen the quadruple helix agenda. The settings will provide effective solutions by promoting proper training, facilitating finance and capital access, and applying digital technology in marketing and branding aspects.
Specifically, the requirement of establishing support by professional and competent consultants in their fields is crucial to developing trust in assistance and consultation services to the community. Excellent quality of service and facilities will not only prevent the failure of MSMEs but will also ensure that they can become independent after proper support is provided. For new business actors, it is critical to guide them in making business feasibility studies, finding the right location, developing business plans, and business proposals. These skills are essential for their businesses (Plechero, 2009;Wilson, 2012). Also, developing quality clinical services requires a culture of transparency, involvement, and openness between the involved parties. Each party should be involved in the design, delivery, and ongoing assessment of the support provided.
Lecturers, as researchers and community service professionals, have done much work and have applied the results of the research to the community on a one-to-one approach.
This method highlights the one-shot facilitator function of a lecturer to the owner of MSME as the partner of conducted community service program. In many cases, the resolution of MSME problems can be resolved but not holistically and continuously due to certain circumstances and limitations. So, it is crucial to redefine the quadruple helix Bootcamp, regular coaching, monitoring, and evaluation of the on-site business location of the participants, benchmarking, and focus group discussion of the taught learning material conducted within six months. Another highlight is the establishment of an entrepreneur community that will lead a subsequent social community service in helping other business starters from inside and outside the BI circumstances.
The establishment of a creative economy clinic is crucial as it is expected to improve the community service program through a stimulus from the directorate of research and community service and internal university funding. The existence of a creative economy clinic in higher education answers criticism from Saad and Zawdie (2011). They highlight the tendency of realization of community service programs in the MSME segment engaged in the non-high-technology and non-capital sectors and the lack of communication and networks that bridge MSMEs, the government, and industry. So, the quadruple helix context has not yet been applied adequately as a result of the low intervention by tertiary institutions.
The establishment of a creative economy clinic will offer increased space for the lecturer's team to provide additional assistance to the actors in the creative economy sector as partners. A more intense engagement between lecturers and MSME actors will further strengthen the value creation of businesses resulting from the more flexible time arrangements and aligning the lecturers' current teaching and other academic activities.
Increased substantial value creation of the managed company will create additional confidence and business independence by the creative economy actors. Consequently, | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 they will be more empowered to gain access to the investor or industry for their business development with or without university intervention.
3.3. The on-campus creative economy clinic: An alternative agenda for upgrading the quality of Lecturers' community service or engagements As explained earlier, lecturers in Indonesia play a role as community service professionals in fulfillment of the Tri Dharma of higher education. This role has been ongoing ever since the Tri Dharma of higher education was embedded in the vision and mission of national higher education. Notably, the dynamic of output resulting from the start of community service programs by lecturers in various universities in Indonesia has significantly evolved. A notable form of development is the shift in the format of the outcomes that were initially based on activities or completed work. The current setup has now turned into a mechanism containing more regular events and product innovations.
It is mandated that this format is to be generated from the applied research conducted by the lecturers' team. The implication is that this applied research is generally performed under the initiation and adoption of appropriate technology-based production machinery and processing by their implementing partners (so-called as Mitra in the local context).
In this current era of higher education management, the demand to produce innovative work has raised critical concerns for the university. It has also been transformed into one of the essential instruments of universities' key performance indicators (KPI), marking the level of success of universities managing their related academic and nonacademic activities in national, regional, and global contexts. One of the KPIs is the establishment of a business incubator, and its contribution, reflecting the implementation of the quadruple helix model among universities, industries, and potential business actors in the case of startup companies.
The existence of business incubators in higher education institutions has brought a particular contribution to the growth and development of business for the majority partners involved in the UMKM sector, especially for those who use the latest technology in the production and operational processes needed to meet the criteria for a startup.
However, in its development, the existence and function of the business incubator tend not to have a significant effect on accelerating the development of startups that Consequently, the existence of a business incubator that is also set as an essential agenda in the national strategic development programs does not reflect the actual value creation. In other words, the effectiveness of the program and its efficiency in budget spending is questionable. Khurana (2017)  More specifically, the proposed methods are included in the establishment of a creative economics clinic in higher education institutions. The establishment of oncampus creative economics clinics is expected to redefine the model and implementation of community service programs that do not support the sustainability of both the MSME and the lecturer. The current mechanism must be reformed to underline the longevity that creates value for MSMEs engaged in the creative economy sector. The specific scheme emphasized by Khurana (2017) has promising outcomes for the adoption of the model that establishes creative economics clinics. It highlights the more intense approach of a combination of competencies of the professional community service and the resources available on the campus to strengthen the innovation and entrepreneurial creativity of partners. Additionally, this more intense approach will provide more effective support for MSMEs to upgrade their capabilities to meet the criteria for technology-based startups.
The modification that enhances the current implementation of community service programs that centralizes the creative economy clinic on campus has advantages for lecturers. One of the significant benefits is the efficiency of their mobility in conducting the Tri Dharma of higher education integrated on campus-site. Consequently, the time efficiency may no longer be an issue. Nevertheless, it also provides access for mobilizing students to conduct entrepreneurial project-based learning practices in their field of science. Further, the students will also develop a new foundation of creativity and innovation for their future projects.

Conclusion
This paper provides the discourse on the establishment of on-campus creative economy clinics as a medium of acceleration and optimization of the role of universities in the development of the creative economy sector, which is currently dominated by MSMEs. Accordingly, the founding of a creative economy clinic on campus can be an alternative to improving the higher level of quality of community service programs through more intense interaction and mentoring between the lecturers as coaches and SMEs as partners. The study related to the development of a creative economy clinical model has not emerged. Therefore, based on our qualitative research, the establishment of a creative economy clinic within the tertiary environment has potential for those involved in the quadruple helix context. Although some cases and research results show that the problems faced by SMEs are solvable, the settlement is not holistic and continuous. For instance, issues related to a lack of capital and bookkeeping management can be overcome by assistance and training from the business incubators. However, the problem of marketing opportunities cannot be fully resolved due to the limitations of | Volume 4, Number 1, 2020 The lecturers, as partners unable to offer thorough technical assistance in fewer than one-two visits or provide remote and virtual consultation basis. Therefore, mentoring and training need to be conducted continuously since the business is a dynamic scheme.
The existence of higher education business incubators that are less than optimal in management and weak governance systems is also the reason for universities in Indonesia to initiate the development of a creative economy clinical model on campus. In the initial stages of developing the model, it is necessary to conduct a preliminary study